01
Go-to village slice
Michael Angelo's Pizza
In Rushsylvania Village • Classic Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Rushsylvania’s own pizza shop turning out saucy, cheesy pies that locals rely on for quick dinners and game nights.[2]
Locally owned and operated since 1997, Michael Angelo’s is the spot most Rushsylvania families have on speed dial for pizza night.[2] Expect well-loaded pies, familiar toppings, and that slightly nostalgic small-town pizzeria feel where the staff knows regulars by name.[2] It’s especially handy when you want to keep things simple—pizza, subs, maybe some wings—and stay right in the village.[2]
02
Best destination pizza
Six Hundred Downtown
Downtown Bellefontaine • Old-World Inspired Pizza Restaurant • Worth-The-Drive Pick
A Bellefontaine mainstay known for artisan-style pies, great garlic knots, and a lively downtown atmosphere that feels special without being fussy.[3]
Six Hundred Downtown in historic downtown Bellefontaine has built a loyal following for its flavorful pizzas and standout garlic knots.[3] The atmosphere is warm and busy in the best way, with an open-kitchen energy that makes it a fun spot for date night or a friends’ dinner.[3] If you don’t mind a short drive from Rushsylvania, this is the place to linger over pizza, a drink, and dessert instead of just grabbing a quick box to go.[3]
03
Family carryout standby
Michael Angelo's Pizza – Kenton
Kenton, East Side • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Feeding A Crowd
The Kenton outpost of Michael Angelo’s brings the same generous toppings and familiar flavors a short drive from Rushsylvania.[2]
The Kenton location of Michael Angelo’s extends the same locally owned, since-1997 formula—solid pies, friendly counter service, and fair prices—into a slightly larger market.[2] It’s a practical pick when you’re already in Kenton running errands or need multiple pizzas, wings, and sides for a team or family gathering.[2] Call ahead on busy nights and you can be in and out quickly with enough food to keep a whole group happy.[2]
04
Chain favorite
Donatos Pizza – Bellefontaine
South Bellefontaine Retail Strip • Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Best For Consistent Classics
A reliable stop for party-cut thin-crust pies when you want something familiar and fast.
Donatos in Bellefontaine is the go-to for people who like classic, party-cut thin crust and predictable, consistent results. Edge-to-edge toppings and plenty of build-your-own options make it easy to satisfy a mix of tastes, from plain pepperoni lovers to veggie fans. With online ordering and quick pickup, it’s especially handy for weeknights, kids’ sleepovers, and post-practice refueling.
05
Craft beer & pizza hangout
Old Scratch Pizza – Troy
Historic Downtown Troy • Lively Craft-Beer And Pizza Bar • Best For A Night Out With Friends
A casual, counter-service spot serving a Midwestern take on Neapolitan-style pies alongside a strong craft beer lineup.[4]
Old Scratch’s Troy location pairs blistered, chewy-crust pizzas with an array of regional craft beers in a big, buzzy space that still feels family-friendly.[4] The setup is walk-in-only and counter-service, so you order at the counter, grab a seat at communal tables, and wait for your name to be called.[4] It’s a bit more of a drive from Rushsylvania, but for groups who want something that feels more like a night out than a simple carryout run, it’s an appealing choice.[4]