01
Best overall pick
Al's Pizza
Fort Loramie, A Quick Drive East Of Russia • Old-School Small-Town Pizzeria • Small-Town Classic
A no-frills spot locals swear by for consistently hot, cheesy pies and friendly, small-town service.
Al's feels like the kind of place every rural community hopes it has: straightforward, generous pizzas made the same way year after year. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, with just enough chew to stand up to heavy toppings. Call ahead on weekend evenings; the steady stream of carryout orders is a good sign you picked the right place.
02
Worth the drive
Bud's Pizza King
Minster, Southwest Of Russia • Classic Tavern-Style Pies • Worth-The-Drive Legend
A long-running local favorite turning out square-cut pies piled high with toppings in a lively small-town setting.
Bud's leans into that classic tavern-style experience, with thin, square-cut pizzas that are ideal for sharing around a table. Their specialty pies come loaded, so a couple of larges can easily feed a whole crew after a game or a day on the lake. It’s a spot where you’re just as likely to bump into neighbors from Russia as you are Minster regulars.
03
Sit-down Italian option
3 Joe's Pizzeria & Trattoria
Piqua, An Easy Highway Run South • Casual Italian Restaurant With Robust Pizza Menu • Best For Lingering Dinners
A full-service Italian spot where the pizza gets as much attention as the pastas and entrees.
If you want more of a night out than a quick pickup, 3 Joe's is the move. The crust is a touch thicker and more artisanal, with a good char and plenty of stretch, and toppings skew a bit more creative than you’ll find in most small-town shops. Pair a specialty pie with a salad and a glass of wine and you’ve got an easy date-night or family dinner destination.
04
Classic thin-crust chain
Cassano's Pizza King
Sidney, To The East Along I-75 • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Best For Thin-Crust Superfans
An area institution known for cracker-thin, square-cut pies with edge-to-edge toppings.
Cassano's is the go-to if you crave that distinctive Dayton-style pizza with an ultra-thin crust and finely chopped toppings spread right to the edge. It’s especially handy for big orders: a stack of their large, square-cut pizzas disappears fast at parties and team gatherings. Online ordering and predictable hours make it a reliable weeknight solution for folks driving back toward Russia.
05
Family-friendly choice
Anna's Pizza & Grill
Anna, Just Off The Interstate South Of Russia • Family-Friendly Pizza And Grill • Best For Families And Teams
A roomy, casual spot combining hearty pizzas with a broad grill menu that keeps everyone at the table happy.
Anna's works well when you’ve got a mixed crowd, thanks to a menu that runs from straightforward pepperoni pies to burgers, wings, and subs. The pizzas lean generous on cheese and toppings, with a sturdy crust that travels well back to Russia if you’re grabbing takeout. With plenty of seating and a laid-back feel, it’s a natural stop after tournaments or long days on the road.