01
Best overall pick
Engine House Pizza Station 2 - Sabina
Along East Washington Street In Sabina • Cozy Small-Town Pizzeria With A Firehouse Theme • Local Favorite For All-Around Pizza Night
A hometown staple where locals grab everything from classic pepperoni pies to loaded specialty pizzas in a laid-back setting.
Engine House Pizza Station 2 feels like the kind of place where the staff knows your order by heart, and that is a big part of the appeal. The crust lands right between soft and crisp, with plenty of cheese and toppings that lean generous rather than precious. It is an easy choice for Friday carryout, team celebrations, or a casual dine-in meal without leaving the village.
02
Best dine-in experience
Generations Pizzeria
Near Downtown Wilmington And Wilmington College • Sit-Down Pizzeria With A Classic Sports-Bar Feel • Best For Lingering Over Pizza And A Game
A Wilmington standby serving hefty pies, cold drinks, and plenty of TVs for when you want more than just a quick box to go.
Generations Pizzeria has the relaxed, slightly buzzy atmosphere that works for everything from college meetups to family dinners. The menu runs deep, but the pizza is the main draw, with well-browned cheese, sturdy crust, and lots of topping combinations that reward sharing a couple of large pies. It is worth the short drive from Sabina when you want to make a night of it instead of eating in the car.
03
Most reliable chain option
Donatos Pizza
Retail Corridor On The East Side Of Wilmington • Fast-Casual Chain Known For Edge-To-Edge Toppings • Best For Quick, Predictable Takeout
Thin, crispy crust and toppings spread right to the edge make this a go-to when you need dinner solved in a hurry.
Donatos in Wilmington delivers exactly what fans of the chain expect: consistent thin-crust pizzas that stay crisp even after the drive back to Sabina. The edge-to-edge topping style means every slice pulls its weight, whether you keep it simple with pepperoni or mix in a specialty pie. Online ordering and efficient pickup make it an easy weeknight solution when nobody wants to cook.
04
Best for classic Italian comfort
La Pizzeria
Side Street Off Downtown Wilmington • Old-School Italian-American Pizza And Pasta Spot • Best For Hearty, Sauce-Forward Pies
A cozy, no-rush stop for thickly topped pizzas, red-sauce favorites, and the kind of comfort food that calls for leftovers.
La Pizzeria leans into the Italian-American side of the spectrum, with rich tomato sauce and generous cheese defining much of the menu. The pizzas come out bubbling and substantial, more knife-and-fork than grab-and-go, which makes them ideal for a sit-down meal or a takeout order you plan to stretch into lunch the next day. It is a solid choice when you want pizza plus garlic bread, pasta, and all the trimmings.
05
Best short-drive value
Bentino's Pizza
Jamestown Village Center • No-Frills Hometown Carryout Shop • Best Value Pies On A Quick Country Drive
Straightforward, budget-friendly pizzas that hit the spot after a drive through the back roads north of Sabina.
Bentino's keeps things simple: familiar crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that favor crowd-pleasing over experimentation. Prices are friendly, portions are solid, and the pace is geared toward carryout, so you can be back on the road quickly. It is a nice option when you do not mind a short rural drive in exchange for an easy, affordable pizza night.