Saint Johns • best pizza

5 Best Pizzerias & Pizza Places for Saint Johns Ohio

Saint Johns may be a tiny dot on the map, but you are only a short, easy drive from some of northwest Ohio’s most satisfying slices. From wood-fired pies in historic downtown Wapakoneta to game-day spreads in St. Marys and low-key carryout in Lima, there is a style for every kind of pizza night. Use this guide to plan a quick bite after errands, a family dinner out, or a relaxed evening with friends. All of these picks are close enough to make a casual weeknight trip feel worthwhile.

View List Contact Us

01 Best overall pick

J. Marie's Wood-Fired Kitchen & Drinks

Downtown Wapakoneta • Upscale-Casual Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Best Sit-Down Experience

A polished yet relaxed spot in downtown Wapak where wood-fired pizzas share the spotlight with craft drinks.

If you want pizza to feel like a proper night out, J. Marie’s is the place locals suggest first. The menu leans on a blistered, wood-fired crust with toppings that range from classic pepperoni to seasonal, chef-driven combinations. It works just as well for a date night as it does for a lingering dinner with friends after a game or show.

02 Game-day favorite

Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill

East St. Marys • Lively Sports-Bar Pizza Grill • Best For Watching The Game

Big screens, big booths, and generously topped pizzas make this St. Marys standby a go-to for groups.

Beer Barrel is built for crowds, with plenty of TVs and a menu that keeps everyone happy. The pizzas are known for their edge-to-edge toppings and party-cut slices that are easy to share. It’s the natural choice when your crew wants to catch the Buckeyes, grab a cold drink, and stretch out over a couple of big pies.

03 Classic carryout choice

Fat Jack's Pizza

West Lima • No-Frills Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Carryout On The Way Home

A long-running Lima favorite known for classic, party-cut pies that travel well back toward Saint Johns.

Fat Jack’s is the kind of place you swing by on the way home from errands in Lima to handle dinner in one stop. Expect straightforward, crowd-pleasing pizzas with crisp crusts, plenty of cheese, and familiar toppings. Order a couple of larges and some breadsticks, and you are set for a casual night in or feeding a small crowd without much planning.

04 Coziest local spot

Guarnieri Pizzeria

Central St. Marys • Small-Town Italian Pizzeria • Best For A Low-Key Dinner

A warmly traditional pizzeria where locals linger over generous pies and Italian comfort dishes.

Guarnieri feels like the kind of small-town spot where the staff quickly learns your regular order. The pizza leans hearty, with substantial crusts and plenty of cheese, and you can round things out with pastas or subs if not everyone at the table wants a slice. It’s an easy, relaxed choice when you want a sit-down meal without any fuss or pretense.

05 Dependable family spot

Pizza Hut

East Wapakoneta • Casual Dine-In Chain Pizzeria • Most Kid-Friendly

A familiar option with roomy booths and the classic Pizza Hut lineup that keeps kids and picky eaters happy.

For many families around Saint Johns, this Wapakoneta Pizza Hut is the default choice when nobody wants to cook. The menu is predictable in the best way, from pan pizzas and stuffed crust to wings and breadsticks, so ordering for a mixed group is easy. It’s close enough for a spontaneous weeknight dinner, with service geared toward getting you in, fed, and back home without a hassle.