01
Best overall pick
Dewey's Pizza Anderson
Beechmont Avenue In Anderson • Lively Sit-Down Pizzeria With Creative Pies • Best All-Around Crowd-Pleaser
A short hop from Salem Heights, Dewey's serves inventive, consistently excellent pies in a polished but relaxed setting.
This is where east-siders go when they want something a notch above standard takeout without feeling fussy. The menu balances classics with smart specialty combos, and the crust hits that sweet spot between chewy and crisp. It’s an easy choice for mixed groups when you need something that will make everyone at the table happy.
02
Cincinnati-style classic
LaRosa's Pizzeria Anderson
Near Anderson Towne Center • Local Chain Serving Cincinnati-Style Pizza • Go-To For Hometown Flavors
For many Anderson and Salem Heights families, LaRosa’s is the default Friday-night pizza, thanks to its sweet sauce and familiar crust.
If you’re curious what “Cincinnati-style” means, this is the place to find out. Thin, edge-to-edge toppings and a distinctive sweet-leaning sauce make these pies instantly recognizable to locals. It’s kid-friendly, reliably fast, and ideal when you want something comforting and unmistakably Queen City.
03
Best for slices
Lucy Blue Pizza Anderson
Clough Pike In Anderson • Cozy Counter-Service Slice Shop • Best For Grab-And-Go Slices
Lucy Blue is the east-side outpost of a beloved local slice shop, perfect when you want a quick, satisfying pizza fix near Salem Heights.
The vibe here is casual and a little scrappy—in a good way—with hot pies cycling out of the oven and big, foldable slices ready to go. It’s great for nights when you don’t want a full sit-down meal but still want something better than generic delivery. Swing by after errands or on your way home and you’ll be back in Salem Heights with dinner in minutes.
04
Neighborhood NY-style
Ramundo's Pizzeria
Mt. Lookout Square • New York–Style Pie And Slice Joint • Great For Big Foldable Slices
Ramundo’s brings classic New York–style pies to the nearby Mt. Lookout bar district, ideal for a casual night out from Salem Heights.
Known for oversized slices and no-nonsense service, Ramundo’s is a staple for east-side pizza fans willing to drive a few extra minutes. The thin, slightly chewy crust and generous toppings make it a natural fit for late dinners or post-game refuels. Pair a slice with a drink at one of the neighboring spots and you’ve got an easy evening beyond the immediate Anderson area.
05
For pan-pizza lovers
Taglio
Columbia-Tusculum Riverfront • Modern Spot Specializing In Pan Pizzas • Best For Thick, Crispy-Edged Pies
Just down the hill from Anderson, Taglio is the east side’s destination for square, pan-style pizzas with serious crunch and creative toppings.
If you like your pizza with a thick, airy base and caramelized edges, Taglio is worth the short drive from Salem Heights. The menu leans modern, with toppings that go beyond the usual pepperoni-and-mushroom routine without feeling gimmicky. It’s a smart pick when you’re in the mood to sit down with friends over a couple of standout pies and a drink.