01
Best overall pick
Pizza Cottage
East Side Of Cambridge Near I-70 • Family-Friendly Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best All-Around Choice Near Salesville
Reliable, crowd-pleasing pies with lots of topping options just off the interstate.
Pizza Cottage in Cambridge is an easy meeting point if your group is coming from different directions. The menu covers everything from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies and stromboli, and portions run generous enough for leftovers. Service is quick, making it a practical stop before or after time on nearby Salt Fork Lake.
02
Best sit-down Italian
Theo's Restaurant
Downtown Cambridge • Old-School Italian Family Restaurant • Best For A Relaxed Dine-In Meal
A Cambridge institution that bakes a solid pizza alongside pasta, gyros, and homemade pies.
Theo's feels more like a classic small-town diner than a dedicated pizzeria, but their pizzas hold their own. Thin, well-browned crust and a slightly sweet sauce make it easy to split a pie while everyone else orders their favorites from the broader menu. It’s a comfortable choice when your group wants more than just pizza.
03
Best carryout close to Salesville
Plus One Pizza
Byesville Village Center • Carryout-Focused Hometown Pizzeria • Best For Takeout And Delivery
Local-style pies piled high with toppings, ideal for calling in on your way home or back to the campground.
Plus One Pizza in Byesville is a go-to for quick, filling takeout within a short drive of Salesville. Crusts tend to be on the thicker, chewier side, with plenty of cheese and toppings that feel very “Ohio pizza night.” Call ahead on weekend evenings, when locals line up for big orders and party trays.
04
Classic road-trip favorite
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Downtown Zanesville • Classic Italian Pizzeria And Restaurant • Worth-The-Drive Old Favorite
Beloved Zanesville landmark known for its saucy, cheese-blanketed pizzas in a cozy dining room.
If you are willing to make the drive west, Adornetto's rewards you with the kind of red-sauce Italian atmosphere that is getting harder to find. Many regulars stick to their signature pizzas, which come out bubbling hot with a generous layer of cheese. It is an easy place to linger over a pitcher of soda or a glass of wine after a day exploring the area.
05
Best for a modern pizza night out
Russo's Wood Fired Pizza
North Zanesville Shopping Corridor • Casual Wood-Fired Pizza Bar • Best For Craft-Style Pies And A Night Out
Neapolitan-inspired, wood-fired pizzas with a modern feel and a solid tap list.
Russo's suits nights when you want something a little more contemporary than a classic corner pizza shop. The menu leans on blistered, wood-fired crusts, creative topping combos, and shareable appetizers. It is a smart pick if your group includes both pizza purists and folks hunting for a few good local beers.