01
Classic local institution
Mary's Pizza Shop
Lisbon • Old-School Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A Lisbon mainstay since the early ’60s, known for its saucy, generously topped pies and no-frills charm.
About 15 minutes northwest of Salineville, Mary’s is the spot longtime locals point to when they talk about “pizza night” in Lisbon. The crust has that slightly chewy, party-cut style you see all over eastern Ohio, with a tangy sauce and plenty of cheese. It’s the kind of place where a large pepperoni and a couple of subs can easily feed a carload after a ballgame.
02
Best for big groups
Fox's Pizza Den
Lisbon • Casual Chain-Style Pizzeria • Best For Families
A crowd-pleasing option with thick, hearty pies and wedges that work well for teams, families, and hungry road crews.
Located in Lisbon, Fox’s is a practical pick when you need to feed a lot of people without overthinking it. The menu leans into loaded specialty pizzas, strombolis, and those signature wedge-style sandwiches that travel well back to Salineville. It’s more polished than a mom-and-pop shop, but still feels small-town friendly and kid-ready.
03
Game-day and takeout pick
East of Chicago Pizza
Lisbon • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Takeout
A reliable stop for customizable crusts and toppings, with plenty of coupons and combo deals for regulars.
East of Chicago in Lisbon is popular with locals who want something quick and predictable for weeknights or game days. You can choose from thin, traditional, or thicker pan-style crusts, and there are enough toppings and specialty combinations to keep a group happy. It’s especially handy if you’re driving back through town to Salineville and want hot pies ready to go.
04
Worth-the-drive scratch pies
R Pizza Place
Columbiana • From-Scratch Family Pizzeria • Destination Pick
A family-run shop in Columbiana turning out handmade dough, balanced sauce, and thoughtfully topped pizzas.
R Pizza Place is a bit of a drive from Salineville, but pizza fans in Columbiana County regularly call it one of the area’s better scratch operations. The dough, sauce, and many toppings are made in-house, giving the pies a fresher, more crafted feel than typical takeout chains. It’s a solid choice when you don’t mind going a little farther for a sit-down pizza night or a higher-quality carryout order.
05
Convenient southern option
East of Chicago Pizza Wellsville
Wellsville • Neighborhood Pizza And Subs Shop • Handy For Nearby Towns
A go-to in Wellsville for customizable pies, subs, and wings, convenient for Salineville residents who head south toward the river.
For those in the southern part of the area, the Wellsville East of Chicago is an easy swing for pizza on the way home from errands or work. The menu mirrors the Lisbon location, with build-your-own and specialty pizzas plus wings and sides that make ordering for a group straightforward. It’s not fancy, but it’s consistent, fast, and close enough to keep on your regular rotation.