01
Best overall pick
Wally's Pizza & Subs
Caldwell Village Center • Casual Family Pizzeria And Sub Shop • Local Favorite
Go-to Noble County stop for generously topped pies and friendly, small-town service.
Wally’s is the kind of place where locals know the staff by name and first-time visitors are treated like regulars. The crust is sturdy enough to hold a heavy load of toppings, and the sauce leans classic and comforting rather than trendy. It’s an easy choice when you want a relaxed, no-frills pizza night after the short drive in from Sarahsville.
02
Best for customizable toppings
Plus 1 Pizza
South Caldwell Near The Fairgrounds • Independent Carry-Out Pizzeria • Best For Customizable Toppings
Build-your-own pizzas with lots of topping choices and a familiar small-chain feel.
Plus 1 Pizza gives you plenty of room to tinker, from extra-cheesy pies to loaded meat or veggie combinations. The crust is a touch thicker than typical delivery chains, with a good balance of chew and crisp. It’s a smart pick when your group is picky and you want to grab carry-out on the way back through Caldwell.
03
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Caldwell Just Off I-77 • National Delivery Chain Store • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Fast, consistent pizza and sides when you want something familiar without leaving the house.
If you are staying in or near Sarahsville and don’t feel like driving, Caldwell’s Domino’s is the reliable fallback. The menu goes well beyond basic pepperoni, with specialty pies, wings, and cheesy breads that travel well back along the country roads. It’s not a destination in itself, but it is hard to beat for convenience and predictability.
04
Best for families
Pizza Hut
Cambridge Near Southgate Parkway • Classic Dine-In Chain Pizzeria • Best For Families
Familiar pan and stuffed-crust pizzas with roomy seating for family get-togethers.
For many Noble and Guernsey County families, a Pizza Hut dinner still feels like a treat, and the Cambridge location fits that bill. The pan pizza comes out with the signature crisp edges and soft center, and the menu is broad enough to keep kids and less adventurous eaters happy. Pair it with a shopping trip or errand run in Cambridge to make the drive from Sarahsville worthwhile.
05
Best for big groups
Creno's Pizza
East Side Of Cambridge • Local Ohio-Style Pizza Chain Shop • Best For Big Groups
Large, party-friendly pies with a classic Ohio pizza style that’s easy to share.
Creno’s is known across eastern Ohio for its big, straightforward pizzas that feed a crowd without drama. The crust is on the thinner side, with plenty of edge-to-edge toppings and a lightly sweet sauce that suits Midwestern tastes. When you are hosting a gathering or ball team and don’t mind the extra drive from Sarahsville, this is an efficient, crowd-pleasing option.