01
Best overall pick
Maddy's Pizzaria
In-Town Sardinia • Cozy Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
The go-to spot right in the village when you want a hot, cheesy pie without leaving Sardinia.
Maddy's feels like the kind of place where they learn your order by heart, with a straightforward menu and generous toppings that hit the craving just right. The crust is hearty enough to stand up to loaded combinations, but still soft at the center. It is an easy pick for weeknight takeout or a low-key family dinner when you want to stay close to home.
02
Best for family dinners
LaRosa's Pizzeria Mt. Orab
Along The Us-32 Strip In Mt. Orab • Sit-Down Family Pizza Restaurant • Family-Friendly Favorite
A roomy, sit-down spot where groups can linger over big pies, pasta, and baskets of breadsticks.
LaRosa's in Mt. Orab is the closest thing to a big-family pizza night within a short drive of Sardinia, with plenty of booths and a menu that goes beyond pizza. The crust leans toward classic Midwest style, with lots of topping combinations and the option to split flavors on larger pies. It works especially well when you have kids in tow or want a place where everyone can find something familiar.
03
Top delivery standby
Snappy Tomato Pizza Mt. Orab
Mt. Orab Shopping Corridor • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Quick Takeout
Reliable for fast, hot pies and breadsticks on nights when cooking is not in the cards.
This Snappy Tomato location is all about convenience: easy ordering, quick turnaround, and consistently hot pizzas at pickup. The crust has a soft, doughy comfort to it, with plenty of cheese and sauce that appeals to kids and adults alike. It is the kind of place Sardinia and Mt. Orab residents lean on for last-minute dinners, movie nights, and impromptu gatherings.
04
Late-night option
Domino's Pizza Hillsboro
Hillsboro Commercial Strip • National Delivery Chain Shop • Late-Night And Game-Day Standby
A dependable choice for customizable pies, wings, and cheesy sides that show up right to your door.
The Hillsboro Domino's is popular with people who want predictable pizza, lots of topping options, and tracking right from the oven to the doorstep. Thin crust, hand-tossed, or pan, you can tailor the style and load it up with sauces and extras for game night or a late shift. It is also a smart choice if you are out toward Hillsboro and need something quick between errands.
05
Classic dine-in chain
Pizza Hut Georgetown
Near The Courthouse Square In Georgetown • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Restaurant • Best For Classic Pan Pizza
A familiar spot for thick, pan-style pies and nostalgia-tinged pizza nights after a day out.
Georgetown's Pizza Hut gives you that classic pan-style crust many people grew up with, along with a salad bar feel and shareable sides. It is an easy meeting point if your group is coming from different directions around Brown County and wants something everyone recognizes. Think team dinners, casual meetups, or a sit-down meal before heading back toward Sardinia.