01
Best overall pick
Gionino's Pizzeria
Ashland – Claremont Avenue Strip • Classic Ohio Italian Takeout & Delivery • Go-To For Big Group Orders
Big, cheesy pies and hearty sides make Gionino's the Ashland-area standby when you need to feed a crowd.
From Savannah, this is the closest place that feels like a true regional favorite rather than just another chain. The crust leans substantial rather than airy, with generous toppings and plenty of cheese that hits the spot on game nights. Add in their well-known fried chicken and jojo potatoes, and you can cover just about any craving in one stop.
02
Classic institution
Leaning Tower of Pizza
Mansfield – North Main Corridor • Old-School Neighborhood Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Loaded Pies
A Mansfield landmark, Leaning Tower is the place for generously topped, old-school pizza worth the drive from Savannah.
If you like your pizza a little nostalgic, this is your spot. The pies come out with a hearty crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and that classic, slightly sweet red sauce that tastes like Friday nights from way back. Pair a pizza with a pitcher and you have a relaxed, no-rush evening that feels very North Central Ohio.
03
Best college-town vibe
Lorenzo's Pizzeria
Oberlin – Downtown By The College • Lively College-Town Slice Shop • Best For A Night Out With Friends
Lorenzo's mixes crisp, satisfying pies with a lively downtown Oberlin energy you do not get closer to Savannah.
On weekends, this spot hums with students, locals, and visitors sharing big pies and pitchers around tight tables. The crust lands in that sweet spot between thin and doughy, sturdy enough for a loaded slice but still crisp at the edges. It is an easy pick if you want to turn a pizza run into a walkable night out in Oberlin.
04
Best for families
Cameo Pizza
Norwalk – Uptown District • Family-Friendly Local Chain • Best For Families And Picky Eaters
Cameo serves crowd-pleasing pies, subs, and wings in a relaxed setting that suits mixed groups and family outings.
This long-running local brand is known for pizza that is easy to like: balanced sauce, plenty of cheese, and crust that stays just crisp enough under toppings. Kids go for the simple pepperoni while adults can branch out into specialty pies or a stromboli. If you are meeting relatives halfway or need a reliable spot for a birthday dinner, it is a low-stress choice that still feels local.
05
Most dependable delivery
Domino's Pizza
Ashland – East Side Near The Highway • Fast-Delivery National Chain • Late-Night And Game-Day Staple
When convenience matters as much as the slice, Domino's in Ashland is the dependable option within easy reach of Savannah.
You are here for speed, online ordering, and consistent pies that show up hot when you need them. The hand-tossed and pan styles both travel well, and the menu of wings, bread twists, and desserts can round out a late-night order. It may not be a special-occasion destination, but locals rely on it when everything else is closed or they just want an easy delivery from town.