01
Best overall pick
Regina's Pizza
Ellet Neighborhood, Akron • Classic Family-Run Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A long-running Akron staple turning out generous, cheese-forward pies that hit the spot every time.
Just a quick hop from Sawyerwood, Regina's feels like the blueprint for an Akron neighborhood pizza shop. Expect a slightly thicker crust with plenty of browned cheese and a sauce that leans comforting rather than flashy. It is the kind of place where regulars know their order by heart and carryout boxes fly out the door on game nights.
02
Best for creative toppings
Totally Baked Pizza
South Akron / Portage Lakes Area • Casual, Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Late-Night Cravings
A go-to for loaded specialty pies, wings, and sides when you want something a little more over-the-top.
Totally Baked leans into big flavors and big portions, with specialty pizzas piled high and plenty of sauces and add-ons to mix things up. It is popular with nearby neighborhoods for delivery, especially when you are feeding a crowd without overthinking it. The crust has enough chew to stand up to the toppings, making even the heavier combinations feel balanced.
03
Classic Akron institution
Luigi's Restaurant
Downtown Akron • Old-School Italian Restaurant • Best For A Sit-Down Night Out
An iconic downtown spot where the pizza comes buried under a mountain of cheese in a cozy, old-world dining room.
Luigi's is a bit of a drive from Sawyerwood but worth it if you want the full Akron pizza experience. The pies are hearty, with a crisp-but-soft crust and a generous blanket of cheese that arrives bubbling at the table. Pair it with a salad and soak up the lived-in atmosphere that feels unchanged in the best possible way.
04
Best for carryout night
Guiseppe's Pizza
North Akron • No-Frills Neighborhood Takeout Shop • Carryout Crowd-Pleaser
Straightforward, well-balanced pies that travel well and please just about everyone at the table.
Guiseppe's keeps things simple, focusing on well-made crust, a clean-tasting sauce, and toppings that do not skimp. It is a smart move when you want reliable pizza without a long wait or a lot of decisions. Grab a couple of large pies and maybe some wings, and you are set for movie night back in Sawyerwood.
05
Best nearby detour
Altieri's Pizza
Tallmadge • Family-Friendly Pizza Joint • Best For Families
A friendly, suburban spot known for its crowd-pleasing pies and kid-ready atmosphere.
Altieri's in Tallmadge makes a nice option when you are already on that side of town and want pizza plus a relaxed sit-down meal. The crust lands in the sweet spot between soft and crisp, with toppings and cheese that feel generous without going overboard. Families appreciate the straightforward menu and the fact that everyone, from picky kids to pizza purists, can find something they like.