01
Best for date night
Nights & Weekends Pizzeria
Bridge Street, Ashtabula Harbor • Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria With A Cozy Bar • Destination For Food-Focused Evenings
Creative wood-fired pies in a lively harbor-side space.
Tucked into the Bridge Street strip, Nights & Weekends turns out blistered, wood-fired pies with thoughtful toppings and a tight, focused menu. The room is small and often buzzing, so it feels more like a night out than a quick slice stop. It is a smart call when you want standout pizza and a drink before or after a walk along the harbor.
02
Harbor classic
Purola's Bridge Street Pizza
Historic Ashtabula Harbor • Classic Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Best For Big Slices After The Beach
Foldable slices and substantial pies right off the harbor strip.
Purola's is the kind of no-nonsense pizza joint where families, boaters, and locals all end up sooner or later. The pies lean generous on cheese and toppings, with a crust sturdy enough to fold and eat on the go. It is ideal for grabbing a box to take back to a rental or refueling after a few hours on the lakefront.
03
Go-to delivery pick
Gionino's Pizzeria Ashtabula
Route 20 Commercial Strip • Carryout And Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Feeding A Crowd At Home
Hearty pizzas, wings, and jojo potatoes delivered around Saybrook.
Gionino's is a regional favorite for nights when you want solid, heavy-on-the-toppings pizza without leaving the couch. The crust runs on the crisp side, and the menu is packed with wings, chicken, and the signature jojo potatoes that tend to vanish first from the box. Locals lean on it for game days, kids' sleepovers, and last-minute group dinners.
04
Neighborhood staple
Capo's Pizza II
West Ashtabula Near The Mall • Casual Family Pizzeria • Best For Relaxed Family Dinners
Thick, cheesy pizzas served alongside familiar Italian comfort food.
Capo's Pizza II feels like the classic local spot where staff recognize regulars and kids know exactly which booth they want. The pizza is sturdy and filling, with a crust that can handle plenty of cheese and toppings, plus a menu of pastas and subs for non-pizza eaters. It is a convenient option when you are running errands on the west side and want to sit down to an easy, crowd-pleasing meal.
05
Chain with a local following
Marco's Pizza Ashtabula
South Ashtabula Near Route 84 • Fast-Service Pizza Chain • Best For Quick, Customizable Orders
Build-your-own pizzas with a range of crusts, sauces, and toppings.
Marco's brings a familiar national name to the local mix, but this store leans into quick service and consistent pies. You can choose from several crust styles and pile on toppings, plus grab salads and subs if your group wants more than pizza. It is especially handy if you're staying in a nearby hotel or rental and want something easy you can order online and pick up fast.