01
Best overall pick
Capraro's Pizza
Cadiz, West Of Scio • Family-Run Pizzeria And Italian Joint • Local Favorite
A cozy small-town shop turning out hearty, well-topped pies that feel made for game night.
Capraro's is the kind of place people in Cadiz grow up on and keep coming back to, with pizzas that lean generous on cheese and toppings. The menu mixes classic pepperoni and sausage pies with a few heavier specialty combinations that travel well back to Scio. Call ahead on Friday and Saturday evenings, when locals tend to stack up the takeout orders.
02
Most reliable chain option
Pizza Hut
Cadiz Shopping Strip • National Chain Dine-In And Carryout • Best For Families
Familiar pan and hand-tossed pizzas in a simple, family-friendly setting just a short hop from Scio.
For families who want something predictable after a long day, the Cadiz Pizza Hut is an easy pick. The menu covers the usual line-up of pan, thin, and stuffed-crust pies, plus wings and breadsticks that make it simple to feed a crowd. It’s also one of the more comfortable sit-down options nearby if you’d rather eat your pizza hot out of the oven than haul it home.
03
Classic sit-down choice
Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House
Dennison/Uhrichsville • Old-School Pizza And Pasta House • Classic Sit-Down Meal
A long-running local favorite where pizza comes with old-school red-sauce-house charm.
Pangrazio's makes the drive toward Dennison or Uhrichsville worth it if you like your pizza with a side of nostalgia. The pies come on a sturdier crust with plenty of cheese, and you can round out the table with pasta, salads, and garlic bread for a full Italian-style meal. It’s a good pick when you’re meeting friends from other towns and want a central spot that still feels local.
04
Best for big-flavor toppings
Gionino's Pizzeria
Carrollton Town Center • Carryout-Focused Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Takeout Night
Loaded, garlic-forward pies and hearty specialty pizzas that hold up well on the drive back to Scio.
Gionino's in Carrollton has a loyal following thanks to its bold sauces and piled-high toppings. The crust runs on the thicker side, making it a solid choice when you want a pizza that stays hot and sturdy on the trip home. Many locals pair their pies with the shop’s fried chicken or jojo potatoes, turning a simple pizza run into a full comfort-food spread.
05
Best for groups
East of Chicago Pizza
Carrollton, Just Off The Square • Buffet-Friendly Pan Pizza Spot • Group-Friendly Choice
Pan and thin-crust pizzas with plenty of topping options, ideal when everyone wants something different.
East of Chicago in Carrollton leans into crowd-pleasing pan pizzas with crispy edges and lots of customization. Between specialty pizzas, build-your-own options, and sides like cheesy bread and wedges, it’s easy to order a mix that keeps both kids and adults happy. It’s especially handy for team dinners or gatherings when you need to feed several people without overcomplicating the plan.