01
Best overall pick
Chester's Pizzeria
North Hamilton • Old-School Neighborhood Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A no-frills Hamilton institution turning out crispy, cheesy pies that are worth the quick drive from Seven Mile.
Chester's feels like the kind of place regulars have been coming to for decades, with friendly service and pizza that leans comfort over trend. Expect generous cheese, a crisp crust, and straightforward toppings done well. It is a reliable choice when you want a classic pizza night without overthinking it.
02
Butler County icon
Richards Pizza
Downtown Hamilton • Family-Friendly Local Chain • Best For Families And Groups
Beloved in Butler County, Richards serves crowd-pleasing pies and subs in a bright, casual setting.
Richards is the spot to meet friends or bring the family after a game, with plenty of seating and fast-moving lines. The pizza has a slightly chewy crust, well-seasoned sauce, and a good balance of toppings, plus their famous steak sandwiches if someone in the group wants a change of pace. It’s the kind of dependable place that makes for an easy weeknight outing from Seven Mile.
03
Takeout night favorite
Calabria Pizza
West Hamilton • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Go-To For Takeout
A low-key Hamilton spot locals lean on for hearty, well-topped pizzas to take home.
Calabria focuses on the essentials: solid pies, generous toppings, and efficient carryout service. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, making it ideal for loading up with pepperoni, veggies, or extra cheese. If you want to pick up a couple of large pizzas on your way back through Hamilton to Seven Mile, this is an easy, satisfying stop.
04
Worth-the-drive classic
Bruno's Pizza
Oxford Uptown • Casual College-Town Pizzeria • Best For A Night Out In Oxford
A long-running Oxford favorite with hefty pies and a lively, student-friendly vibe.
Bruno's feels like a proper college-town pizzeria: a little noisy, very welcoming, and serious about its pizza. The crust is substantial enough to support heavy toppings, making their specialty pies a good bet if you like bold combinations. Pair a visit with a stroll around uptown Oxford and it becomes an easy, fun evening trip from Seven Mile.
05
Thin-crust cult favorite
Cassano's Pizza King
East Middletown • Regional Thin-Crust Chain • Best For Thin-Crust Cravings
A Dayton-area original known for cracker-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and nostalgic charm.
Cassano's serves the kind of ultra-thin, square-cut pizza that splits a room—in a good way. The crust is crisp, the sauce leans tangy, and toppings go right to the edge, making each piece a satisfying bite. When you are in the mood for something lighter and snackable rather than a heavy, doughy pie, the Middletown location is an easy option from Seven Mile.