01
Best overall pick
Romeo's Pizza
Wadsworth – Great Oaks Trail • Handcrafted Delivery And Carryout Pizzeria • Best For Dependable Delivery
A go-to for thick, cheesy pies with a slightly sweet sauce, plus wings and subs, delivered reliably to Sharon Center and nearby townships.
Romeo’s in Wadsworth is often the easiest answer when a group just wants solid, crowd-pleasing pizza without overthinking it. The crust leans hearty, the toppings are generous, and the specialty combinations cover everything from classic pepperoni to bolder, sauce-forward builds. It’s especially handy on busy weeknights when you want dinner to show up hot at the door rather than making a drive into town.
02
Downtown night-out pick
Courthouse Pizzeria
Medina Public Square • Historic Downtown Slice Shop • Best For A Night On The Square
A lively little shop just off the Medina courthouse square, serving foldable New York-style slices and whole pies before or after strolling downtown.
Courthouse Pizzeria is the classic choice when you want to combine pizza with a walk around Medina’s historic square. Slices come out fast, with a thin, foldable crust and enough char to keep things interesting, and whole pies are easy to split at one of the small tables. It’s ideal before local events on the square or as a casual stop after errands in Medina.
03
For creative pizza fans
Ohio Valley Pizza Co.
East Medina • Artisan Pan-Pizza Spot • Best For Craft Toppings
Thick, airy square pies with crisp edges and inventive toppings make this a magnet for pizza fans willing to drive a few extra minutes.
Ohio Valley Pizza Co. leans into a modern, artisan take on pan-style pies, with a dough that’s light inside, crispy on the edges, and built to hold serious toppings. Expect rotating combinations that go beyond the usual, along with upgraded ingredients that justify the trip from Sharon Center. It’s a smart pick when you’re in the mood to try something a bit different from the standard delivery chain options.
04
Family-friendly favorite
Dominic's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
North Court Street, Medina • Family-Run Italian Restaurant • Best For Sit-Down Family Meals
A cozy, old-school spot known for its generous pizzas, red-sauce pastas, and a relaxed dining room that works well for families and groups.
Dominic’s is where many Medina-area families end up when they want pizza plus a full Italian menu under one roof. The pies are substantial, with plenty of cheese and toppings, and you can round things out with salads, pasta, and garlic bread for a proper sit-down meal. From Sharon Center, it’s an easy drive for a low-key Friday-night dinner that still feels like going out.
05
Classic Italian night out
Santo Suossos Pizza Pasta Vino
South Medina • Old-School Italian Dining Room • Best For Lingering Dinners
A full-service Italian restaurant where the pizza shares the spotlight with pasta, wine, and a comfortable, linger-friendly atmosphere.
Santo Suossos is a smart choice when you want pizza but also want a proper sit-down evening with wine and table service. The pizzas come on a well-seasoned crust with balanced sauce and cheese, and the rest of the menu lets everyone at the table find something they like. It’s a bit more of a night-out destination than a quick slice stop, making it a nice option for date nights or relaxed dinners with friends.