01
Best overall pick
Iacono's Restaurant
Shawnee Hills On Dublin Road • Classic Family Italian Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dine-In
Family-friendly pies and red-sauce classics in a cozy dining room just off Dublin Road.[1][5]
Iacono's traces its menu back to Sicilian-inspired family recipes, so the crust, sauce, and toppings all lean traditional in the best way.[5] The restaurant sits on Dublin Road near Shawnee Hills, making it an easy choice when you want a proper sit-down meal rather than pure carryout.[1] It is the spot to choose when you are in the mood for a big shared pizza, a salad, and a lingering conversation rather than a quick dash in and out.[1][5]
02
Best classic carryout
Pizzas By George
Shawnee Hills Village Strip • Old-School Takeout Counter • Best For Grab-And-Go
Carryout-only pies on Dublin Road with coupons, lottery tickets, and a small-town counter vibe.[2]
Pizzas By George is a straightforward, no-frills shop on Dublin Road in Shawnee Hills: you call in, swing by, and walk out with a hot box in hand.[2] The place leans into its carryout-only model, pairing classic pies with deals like $3 off any large pizza for carryout and even selling Ohio Lottery games at the counter.[2] It is ideal for low-key weeknights when you want something local and dependable without driving down into Columbus traffic.[2]
03
Worth-the-drive pies
Bazemore Pizza Company
Riverside Drive, Upper Arlington • Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For A Sit-Down Night Out
A polished neighborhood pizzeria on Riverside Drive in Upper Arlington, close enough for a quick pizza run from Shawnee Hills.[3]
Bazemore Pizza Company sits on Riverside Drive in Upper Arlington, an easy straight shot south for anyone coming from the Shawnee Hills and Scioto River corridor.[3] It feels more like a modern neighborhood cafe than a corner slice joint, so it works nicely when you want pizza plus a relaxed sit-down atmosphere instead of pure takeout.[3] It is a smart pick for meeting friends who are coming from different parts of town and want a central, easy-to-find spot along the river.[3]
04
Best for game nights
JT's Pizza & Pub
West Worthington / Northwest Columbus • Lively Pub-Style Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Casual Hangs
A high-energy pub on West Granville Road where pizza shares the spotlight with cold beer and bar food staples.[3]
JT's Pizza & Pub on West Granville Road in northwest Columbus is an easy meet-up point if your crew is scattered between Shawnee Hills, Worthington, and Dublin.[3] The vibe is casual and social, with pizza, wings, and pints anchoring the menu so you can settle in for a full evening rather than just a quick bite.[3] It is the place to choose when you need room for a group and want that classic neighborhood-pub energy alongside your pie.[3]
05
Old-school north-side option
The Pizza House
North Columbus, East Lincoln Avenue • Traditional No-Frills Pizza Joint • Best For Classic Columbus-Style Pies
A straightforward North Side pizza joint on East Lincoln Avenue that feels pleasantly rooted in old-school Columbus pizza culture.[3]
The Pizza House on East Lincoln Avenue sits on Columbus's North Side, so it is more of a planned outing from Shawnee Hills than a quick walkable stop.[3] In return, you get sturdy, familiar pies from a simple, comfortable room that feels like the kind of place regulars have been dropping into for years.[3] It is a good choice when you are already headed toward the North Side and would rather support a long-running local spot than default to a national chain.[3]