01
Best overall pick
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek • Modern Farm-To-Table Pizzeria • Destination-Worthy Pie Spot
A serious pizza stop with creative toppings, great crust, and a casual, buzzy small-town feel.
If you are willing to drive a bit from Sherrodsville, Park Street Pizza in Sugarcreek is the place locals recommend first. The menu leans on quality ingredients and inventive topping combos, but you can still get a perfectly executed pepperoni or simple Margherita. It feels more like a little food destination than a typical small-town pizza joint, making it a smart pick for date night or a relaxed group dinner.
02
Best for loaded toppings
Gionino's Pizzeria
New Philadelphia • Hearty Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Carryout
Thick cheese, generous toppings, and classic Ohio pizzeria vibes make this a go-to takeout stop.
Gionino's in New Philadelphia is the spot when you want a big, cheesy pie that can actually feed a crowd back in Sherrodsville. Their pizzas come piled with toppings, and the crust hits that middle ground between chewy and crisp. Order a couple larges with JoJo potatoes and you have an easy game-night spread without much planning.
03
Best for variety
East of Chicago Pizza
New Philadelphia • Casual Buffet-Style Chain Pizzeria • Best For Families And Groups
A flexible option with pan, thin, and specialty pies plus a salad bar that keeps everyone happy.
East of Chicago in New Philadelphia is tailor-made for mixed groups where everyone wants something different. You can build your own pie, go for thick pan slices, or sample several styles if you hit the buffet hours. It is an easy choice for families driving up from Sherrodsville who want predictable prices, lots of options, and no fuss.
04
Best late-night option
Domino's Pizza
New Philadelphia • Fast-Delivery Chain Spot • Reliable Late-Night Pick
When it is late, you are hungry, and you want your go-to order to taste exactly like you expect, this Domino's delivers.
For those nights when you do not feel like planning ahead, Domino's in New Philadelphia is the straightforward answer. The menu is familiar, the online ordering is quick, and you can customize everything from crust type to sauce level. It is not a destination in itself, but it is the dependable option Sherrodsville locals lean on when convenience matters more than atmosphere.
05
Best for dine-in nostalgia
Pizza Hut
New Philadelphia • Classic Family-Chain Pizzeria • Sit-Down Family Choice
A familiar dine-in spot where pan pizzas, breadsticks, and big red cups of soda still feel like a small-town ritual.
New Philadelphia’s Pizza Hut is the kind of place that works well for an easy family meal after errands or a trip into town from Sherrodsville. The pan and stuffed-crust pies are comfortingly predictable, and there is enough space for kids, grandparents, and everyone in between. It is not fancy, but it delivers that old-school chain-pizza nostalgia in a relaxed setting.