01
Best overall pick
Iron Horse Brews
Sherwood Village Center • Brewpub With Artisan-Style Pizza • Local Hangout With Great Pies
A family-friendly brew house in the heart of Sherwood that pairs craft beer with surprisingly good house pizzas.
If you want to stay right in Sherwood, Iron Horse Brews is the place to settle in for a hot pie and a cold pint. The menu leans into shareable pizzas with plenty of toppings, plus rotating specials that keep regulars interested. It’s an easy choice when you want a laid-back evening without driving into Defiance.
02
Worth-the-drive carryout
The Drop Zone Pizzeria
Ayersville, East Of Sherwood • Small-Town Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Hearty Carryout From Us‑24
Ayersville’s Drop Zone is a go-to for thick, generously topped pizzas that travel well back to Sherwood.
Just a short hop east on US‑24, The Drop Zone Pizzeria is a favorite for families headed home after games and practices. The crust is sturdy, the toppings are piled on, and the portions suit hungry groups. Call ahead on busy nights; this little shop can get backed up when the local teams are in season.
03
Game-night staple
Padrone's Pizza
South Defiance • Classic Regional Pizzeria • Reliable Crowd-Pleaser
A Defiance standby with a big menu of pizzas, subs, and wings that works well for feeding a group.
Padrone’s in Defiance is often the first call for birthday parties, team gatherings, and casual get-togethers. The crust runs in the middle ground between thin and thick, with a slightly sweet sauce that many locals swear by. Round out a pizza order with wings or cheesy breadsticks and you’re set for a full evening at home.
04
Fast delivery pick
Marco's Pizza
North Clinton Street Corridor, Defiance • Chain Pizzeria With Delivery And Carryout • Best For Quick, Customizable Orders
A familiar name that turns out consistently solid pizzas with plenty of topping and crust options.
When convenience matters as much as the pie, Marco’s in Defiance is a practical option for Sherwood residents. You can build your own pizza, try one of their specialty combinations, or add on salads and subs to cover different tastes. It’s especially handy on busy weeknights when you want dinner handled with a phone call or a few taps.
05
Chain comfort choice
Papa Johns Pizza
Defiance Commercial Strip • National Chain With Familiar Flavors • Best For Consistent, Sauce-Forward Pies
A go-to for fans of Papa Johns’ sweeter sauce, garlic butter cups, and predictable chain pizza comfort.
Papa Johns in Defiance is a solid fallback when everyone already knows what they like to order. The pizzas are heavy on cheese and sauce, with add-ons like garlic knots and desserts to round out a delivery. It’s not the most adventurous choice on the list, but it reliably hits the spot for a classic chain-style pizza night.