01
Best overall pick
LaRosa's Pizzeria Anderson
Near Anderson Towne Center • Family-Friendly Cincinnati-Style Pizzeria • Local Standby For Families
The Anderson outpost of LaRosa's is the dependable east-side choice for big, shareable pies and crowd-pleasing toppings.
If you grew up in Greater Cincinnati, LaRosa's is probably what you picture when someone says pizza night. The Anderson location keeps that tradition going with buttery crusts, sweet-leaning sauce, and a topping list that makes it easy to keep a whole table happy. It’s an especially good pick for family dinners before or after activities along the Beechmont strip.
02
Best for crispy edges
Taglio Anderson
Beechmont Avenue Corridor • Modern Detroit-Style Pizza Bar • Best For Crispy, Cheesy Edges
Taglio brings thick, airy Detroit-style squares with lacy, caramelized cheese edges to the Anderson stretch of Beechmont.
Taglio’s Anderson shop turns out hefty pans of Detroit-style pizza with a crisp bottom, light interior, and the kind of corner pieces people fight over. Sauces and toppings lean creative without getting fussy, so you can branch out from pepperoni or stick with the classics. It’s a natural choice when you want something a little more indulgent than a standard round pie.
03
Classic neighborhood spot
Mio's Pizza Anderson
Five Mile Road Area • Cozy Neighborhood Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Casual Dine-In With Friends
Mio's in Anderson feels like the archetypal east-side neighborhood pizza place, with cracker-thin crusts and a laid-back taproom vibe.
Mio’s bakes a thinner, tavern-style crust that holds up well under generous cheese and toppings, making it ideal for sharing a few pizzas with a group. The dining room leans casual and TV-filled, so it works well for catching a game over a pitcher and a pie. Locals appreciate that it still feels like a low-key east-side hangout rather than a polished chain.
04
Best quick slice stop
Ramundo's Pizzeria Mount Washington
Mount Washington • New York–Style Slice Shop • Grab-And-Go Favorite
Ramundo's in nearby Mount Washington is where many Sherwood-area residents head for oversized New York–style slices and a relaxed counter-service setup.
This spot is known for large, foldable slices that hit the table fast, along with whole pies when you have a bigger crew to feed. The atmosphere is simple and functional, making it an easy stop before heading back down Beechmont or toward the river. It’s especially handy when you want something better than national-chain pizza but don’t have time for a full sit-down meal.
05
Best late-night option
Goodfellas Pizzeria Columbia-Tusculum
Columbia-Tusculum Riverfront • Lively Late-Night New York–Style Pizzeria • Late-Night Crowd-Pleaser
Goodfellas in Columbia-Tusculum rewards the short drive from Sherwood with big, foldable slices, bustling energy, and a full bar upstairs.
Set in a historic building near the riverfront, Goodfellas feels more like an urban slice joint than a suburban storefront, which is part of the appeal. You can grab a slice at the counter or settle in upstairs with a whole pie and a drink if you have more time. For Sherwood residents meeting friends closer to the city or looking for pizza after an evening out, this is the go-to choice.