01
Best overall pick
Slice of Heaven
Shiloh Village Center • Small-Town Pizzeria Counter • Local Favorite For Classic Pies
The hometown spot for straightforward, crowd-pleasing pizza right on West Main Street.
Slice of Heaven is the kind of place where the staff knows regulars by name and the pizza leans classic—plenty of cheese, a sturdy crust, and familiar toppings done well. It’s an easy go-to for takeout on a weeknight or a low-key family dinner after a game. Round out your order with wings or a sub and you’ve got the small-town pizzeria experience in one stop.
02
Classic local institution
Leaning Tower of Pizza
Central Mansfield • Old-School Tavern-Style Pizza Joint • Best For Crispy Thin Crust
A Mansfield standby known for its square-cut, tavern-style pies and no-frills, old-school atmosphere.
Leaning Tower of Pizza has been a Mansfield fixture for decades, the kind of place locals mention first when you ask where to get a classic pie. Expect a thin, crispy crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and that nostalgic square-cut style that works perfectly for sharing. It’s a relaxed, slightly retro spot that’s ideal when you want a sit-down pizza night with a bit of local character.
03
Best pizza-and-chicken combo
Gionino's Pizzeria Mansfield
South Mansfield • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Great For Takeout Feasts
A regional favorite for hearty pies, fried chicken, and jojos that can feed a whole crew.
Gionino’s Pizzeria in Mansfield is built for big appetites and bigger groups, with generous toppings and crusts that hold up well on the drive back to Shiloh. Many locals pair their pizza with the shop’s fried chicken and seasoned potato wedges, making it a one-call solution for game days or family gatherings. It’s more of a grab-and-go spot than a dine-in destination, but the menu breadth makes it a strong takeout play.
04
Big-slice value pick
Two Cousins Pizza & Subs
West Mansfield • Casual Slice-And-Subs Shop • Best For Hearty Slices And Subs
Known for oversized slices, loaded subs, and unfussy counter service.
Two Cousins Pizza & Subs is where Mansfield leans when it wants big portions and straightforward, satisfying pizza. Slices tend to be on the larger, New York–inspired side, with a bit of chew and plenty of cheese, and the sub lineup makes it easy to keep non-pizza folks happy. It’s a relaxed, order-at-the-counter operation—perfect for a quick lunch stop in town or a laid-back dinner to bring back home.
05
Most reliable late-night option
Domino's Pizza Mansfield
Mansfield Shopping Corridor • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery And Deals
A dependable choice for customizable pizzas, fast delivery, and frequent specials when it’s already dark out.
When it’s late, you’re tired, and you just want something hot delivered without surprises, Domino’s in Mansfield is hard to beat. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to customize crusts, sauces, and toppings exactly how your group likes them, and the mix-and-match deals help keep costs in check. It may not have the charm of a mom-and-pop shop, but for convenience and predictability on a drive back to Shiloh, it earns its spot on the list.