01
Classic Dayton institution
Marion's Piazza – North Dixie
North Dixie Drive, East Of Shiloh • Old-School Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Best Big-Group Choice
Classic Dayton-style thin-crust pizza in a big, bustling dining room that's an easy meetup spot from Shiloh.
Marion's North Dixie location is a go-to when you have a crowd and everyone wants their own topping combo. The ultra-thin, square-cut pies arrive fast, making it ideal for pre-game dinners or casual family nights. Expect a loud, nostalgic room and plenty of locals who have been coming here for decades.
02
Dayton original near Shiloh
Cassano's Pizza King – North Main
North Main Street, Just South Of Shiloh • Retro Counter-Service Pizzeria • Best For Nostalgic Flavors
Dayton-born chain serving crispy, edge-to-edge topping pies just a few stoplights from Shiloh.
If you grew up in the Dayton area, Cassano's flavor is probably your benchmark for local pizza. This North Main outpost is close enough for a quick pickup run, with those familiar cracker-thin crusts and generously loaded toppings. It is especially popular on Friday nights when families and longtime regulars swing through for a no-fuss dinner.
03
Most convenient takeout
Donatos Pizza – North Main
North Main Street Corridor • Modern Delivery-And-Carryout Shop • Best For Busy Weeknights
Consistently crisp, edge-to-edge pepperoni pizzas with easy online ordering and quick pickup.
When you need pizza on the table without overthinking it, Donatos on North Main is the dependable option. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to lighter veggie and cauliflower-crust picks, so everyone in the house can find something. Order ahead, swing by from Shiloh, and you can be back home with hot pies in under half an hour on most nights.
04
Best tavern pie
Little York Tavern & Pizza
Little York Road, Vandalia • Lively Tavern And Pizza Joint • Best For Pizza And A Beer
Neighborhood tavern known for hefty, cheesy pizzas and a lively bar vibe north of Shiloh.
Little York Tavern feels like the kind of place regulars have been claiming barstools for years, and the pizza is a big part of the draw. The crust is sturdy enough to hold generous cheese and toppings, making it perfect with a cold draft beer. Go for a casual night out, live music on select evenings, and a pie that tastes like classic Midwestern tavern pizza should.
05
Worth-the-drive destination
Old Scratch Pizza – Downtown Dayton
Downtown Dayton • Wood-Fired Craft Pizzeria • Best For Foodies And Craft Beer Fans
Wood-fired Neapolitan-inspired pies with creative toppings in a big, airy taproom-style space.
Old Scratch is a short drive south from Shiloh but feels like a night out in the city. The pizzas come with blistered, chewy crusts and toppings that range from classic margherita to combinations with hot honey, house-made sausage, and pickled peppers. Long communal tables, a strong craft beer lineup, and counter service make it easy to settle in with friends and share a couple of pies.