Shreve may be a small village, but it sits within easy reach of some surprisingly good pizza. From a Main Street staple to long-running parlors in nearby Wooster and Millersburg, you can cover a lot of styles in a short drive. Use this list to plan an easy night out or a quick takeout stop after a day on the back roads.
Simple, satisfying pies in a no-frills setting right in the heart of Shreve.
This is the spot locals think of first when someone says, "Let’s just get a pizza." Expect straightforward crust, plenty of cheese, and friendly counter service that keeps things moving. It is ideal for an easy carryout order when you want something close to home without overthinking it.
Hearty, loaded pizzas in a throwback dining room that feels like a local secret.
Coccia House has a loyal following for its generously topped, fork-and-knife style pies and cozy, lived-in atmosphere. The crust has a bit of chew, the toppings run right to the edge, and leftovers are almost guaranteed. Go when you have time to linger, share a couple of pizzas, and see why Wooster residents recommend it to visitors.
Ohio-based chain known for flavorful crust, generous toppings, and quick turnarounds.
Gionino's is a go-to when you want something a notch above basic delivery but still fast and convenient. The crust has a distinct garlicky kick, and combo orders with pizza, wings, and JoJo potatoes make it easy to feed a crowd. It is a smart choice for game nights or weekend cabin rentals outside Shreve where delivery can still reach you.
Build-your-own and specialty pies with plenty of pan-crust options and a casual buffet setup.
If you are heading south toward Millersburg, East of Chicago is an easy stop where everyone can find something they like. Thick, airy pan crusts, dessert pizzas, and a salad bar make it especially practical for youth teams or extended families. It is more about variety and value than gourmet flair, but it hits the spot after a long day out.
Well-known pan and stuffed-crust pies in a sit-down setting that is easy with kids in tow.
For many families around Shreve, this is the default choice when you want predictable pizza, roomy booths, and plenty of soda refills. The menu covers personal pan pizzas, shareable pies, wings, and pastas, so picky eaters are easy to accommodate. It is also a convenient stop when you are already up near the highway running errands in Wooster.