Silver Lake may be a quiet village, but it sits in the middle of one of Northeast Ohio’s most underrated pizza corridors. Within a quick drive you can bounce between old-school Akron institutions, lively Cuyahoga Falls patios, and low-key slice shops that deliver right to the lake. These five spots are where locals actually order from when they’re craving a pie.
A legendary red-sauce joint with loaded pies and a cozy, no-frills dining room.
If you ask long-time locals where to go for a classic pie, Luigi’s is the name that comes up first. Thick-with-cheese pizzas, simple toppings, and a nostalgic dining room make it feel like a time capsule in the best way. Go when you’re in the mood for comfort food and don’t mind a bit of a wait on busy nights.
Creative specialty pies, a well-chosen beer list, and a polished but relaxed dining room.
Dewey’s at Portage Crossing is where Silver Lake meets up with Cuyahoga Falls for modern, shareable pies. The menu leans into inventive combinations, from loaded veggie options to meat-heavy crowd-pleasers, all on a chewy, flavorful crust. It’s an easy choice when you need a place that works for kids, craft beer fans, and picky eaters at the same table.
Big, satisfying pies and slices that hit the spot when you want pizza without leaving the couch.
Totally Baked is the move when you’re staying in around Silver Lake and want a hot box on the doorstep. Toppings are generous, crusts are sturdy enough to handle extra cheese and sauce, and the whole menu feels built for sharing with friends. It’s especially handy for game nights, movie marathons, and impromptu gatherings that run late.
A low-key spot where crisp-edged pies, wings, and cold beer keep the regulars coming back.
Tim’s feels like the kind of place you end up calling your “usual” after a few visits. The pizza leans hearty and straightforward, with a crust that holds up under classic toppings and plenty of cheese. Add in friendly service, TVs for the game, and a laid-back pub vibe, and it becomes an easy go-to just a short drive from Silver Lake.
Generous pizzas alongside Greek and Italian comfort dishes in a no-rush, family-friendly setting.
Athena’s is a solid choice when not everyone at the table is set on pizza but you still want a good pie in the mix. The pizzas come out substantial, with plenty of toppings, and you can round out the meal with salads, pastas, and Greek favorites. It’s the kind of place where portions are big, prices are fair, and nobody feels hurried out the door.