01
Classic neighborhood staple
Krimmer's Italianette Pizza
Silverton Village • Old-School Family Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A Silverton mainstay turning out saucy, cheese-heavy pies in a no-frills, everyone-knows-everyone dining room.
If you ask longtime residents where they grew up eating pizza, Italianette comes up fast. The crust leans classic Midwest—sturdy, with a generous layer of melty cheese and a sweet-leaning red sauce that feels nostalgic in the best way. It’s the kind of place where team parties, weeknight takeout, and Friday traditions all converge, and the staff usually remembers your usual after a few visits.
02
Best for family dinners
Dewey's Pizza – Kenwood
Kenwood / Montgomery Road • Lively Sit-Down Pizzeria • Family-Friendly Favorite
A polished but relaxed spot near Kenwood with creative specialty pies, solid salads, and a smooth dine-in experience.
Just a few minutes southwest of Silverton, the Kenwood Dewey’s is a go-to when you want something a step up from takeout but still easy with kids in tow. The menu balances reliable classics with fun options like seasonal specials and white-sauce combinations, plus salads that feel like more than an afterthought. Open kitchen views and quick service keep the energy up without veering into chaotic.
03
Best for crispy, creative slices
Taglio – Montgomery
Montgomery Road Corridor • Modern Slice-Focused Pizzeria • Go-To For Inventive Toppings
Known for its crispy, almost caramelized-edge pies and chef-minded toppings, a quick drive north from Silverton.
Taglio’s Montgomery outpost draws pizza fans who care as much about texture as toppings. The crust is airy yet sturdy, with those coveted browned edges that hold up under bold combinations like hot honey, specialty meats, and punchy veggies. It’s an easy choice when you’re craving something more adventurous than standard delivery without committing to a full white-tablecloth night out.
04
Best date-night option
A Tavola – Madeira
Madeira Business District • Neapolitan-Inspired Pizzeria • Pizza For A Night Out
A cozy Madeira spot turning out blistered, Neapolitan-style pies with thoughtful toppings and a grown-up atmosphere.
A short drive east of Silverton, A Tavola in Madeira feels like a small neighborhood trattoria where the pizza just happens to steal the show. The crust is soft in the center with leopard-spotted edges, ideal for simple combinations like fresh mozzarella and basil or more layered, seasonal toppings. It’s a strong pick when you want a proper sit-down meal with a glass of wine and lingering conversation rather than a quick in-and-out slice.
05
Late-night slice standby
Ramundo's Pizzeria
Mt. Lookout Square • Casual New York–Style Slice Shop • Best For Big Slices And Late Hours
A laid-back Mt. Lookout counter spot slinging oversized New York–style slices that hit the spot after a night out.
Ramundo’s is the answer when you’re coming back from the east side of town and realize you’re starving. The slices are big, foldable, and generously topped, with enough varieties in the case that everyone can grab something different without slowing down the line. It’s more stand-up counter and quick box pickup than sit-and-linger, which is exactly the charm when all you really want is a hot, straightforward slice done right.