01
Best overall pick
Dewey's Pizza – Harper's Point
Harper's Point • Lively Sit-Down Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Any Occasion
A polished yet easygoing pizzeria with consistently great specialty pies and quick, friendly service.
Just down Montgomery Road at Harper's Point, this Dewey's location is where many Sixteen Mile Stand residents default for pizza night. The open kitchen, big booths, and half-and-half pie options make it easy to please a mixed group. Expect chewy, flavorful crust, creative toppings (the Edgar Allan Poe is a standout), and service that keeps the pace even on packed weekends.
02
Top pick for slices
Taglio – Montgomery
Montgomery Business District • Modern Slice Shop And Bar • Best For Craft Slices And Drinks
A sleek counter-service spot known for crisp-edged square slices, inventive toppings, and a strong tap list.
Taglio’s Montgomery outpost brings a more urban pizza-bar feel to the Montgomery Road strip, a quick hop from Sixteen Mile Stand. Their thick, airy square pies with caramelized cheese edges are ideal if you want something a little more indulgent than standard delivery pizza. Pair a couple of slices with a local beer and you’ve got an easy weeknight dinner that still feels like a treat.
03
Old-school favorite
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta
Montgomery Near I-275 • Classic New York–Style Pizzeria • Neighborhood Standby
A no-frills, New York–leaning shop turning out big foldable slices, hearty pies, and crowd-pleasing pastas.
Set along Montgomery Road just north of the main Montgomery strip, Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta feels like the kind of spot locals grow up with. The thin, floppy slices, garlic knots, and red-sauce pastas make it a natural fit for takeout or a casual family meal. It’s not trying to be trendy—just reliable, generous portions at fair prices a few minutes from Sixteen Mile Stand.
04
Worth the drive
Two Cities Pizza Co.
Historic Mason • Ny-And-Chicago–Style Pizzeria • Destination For Deep-Dish And Thin-Crust
A themed pizzeria that treats both New York thin-crust and Chicago deep-dish with equal seriousness.
In downtown Mason, Two Cities is the place to go when you’re willing to drive a bit for a memorable pizza night. The menu is split between crisp New York rounds and hefty Chicago pies, so you can satisfy different cravings at one table. The restored building, subway-tiled interior, and friendly staff give it a destination feel that still works for families and groups from the Sixteen Mile Stand area.
05
Most inventive pies
Mad Monks Pizza
East Mason / Reading Road • Creative Gourmet Pizzeria • Best For Adventurous Toppings
A Mason shop that leans into bold topping combinations and specialty pies without losing the basics.
Mad Monks, tucked along Reading Road in Mason, is a smart choice when everyone’s bored with the same old pepperoni. Their menu runs from classic combinations to loaded specialty pies with unexpected sauces, meats, and veggies, plus solid gluten-free and alternative options. It’s an easy drive up US-42 from Sixteen Mile Stand and a good call for sharing a few different pizzas around the table.