01
Best overall pick
Montell's Pizza
Somerset Village Center • Old-School Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A longtime Somerset staple turning out generous, classic pies that taste like small-town Ohio in a box.
Montell’s is the spot locals rattle off first when you ask where to get pizza in Somerset. The crust leans sturdy rather than fussy, built to handle plenty of toppings and still reheat well the next day. Call ahead on weekend evenings—between ball teams, families, and regulars, the ticket stack can get deep.
02
Classic small-town slice
Nick's Somerset Pizza
North Columbus Street, Somerset • Thick-Crust Family Shop • Best For Hearty Carryout
Comfort-food pizza with plenty of cheese, friendly counter service, and prices that make feeding a crew easy.
Nick’s leans into the hearty side of Midwest pizza: think thick toppings, plenty of cheese, and party-cut squares that disappear fast. It’s the kind of place where the staff tends to recognize repeat orders and doesn’t blink at big game-day calls. If you like to tinker, build-your-own pies here are especially forgiving of loaded combinations.
03
Upscale pizza night
Strong & Co. Restaurant + Bar
Somerset Main Street • Brick-Oven Restaurant & Bar • Best For Pizza And A Drink
A polished spot on the square where you can pair a crafted pizza with a proper cocktail or local beer.
While Strong & Co. is a full restaurant and bar, its stone-baked pizzas have become a go-to option for date nights and group dinners in town. Expect thoughtfully topped pies—often with seasonal ingredients—that land somewhere between bar pizza and chef-driven flatbreads. Grab a seat near the bar if you want a livelier vibe, or tuck into a table by the windows to watch the square go by.
04
Worth-the-drive classic
Adornetto's Pizzeria
Zanesville East Side • Classic Italian Pizzeria • Destination Pie From Town
A Zanesville institution known for thin, edge-to-edge toppings that many Somerset folks happily drive for.
If you ask around Somerset where people go when they’re willing to travel for pizza, Adornetto’s in Zanesville comes up fast. The pies are thin but sturdy, loaded right out to the edge so every slice feels like a corner piece. Plan for a bit of a wait on busy nights, but the old-school atmosphere and consistently good pizza justify the extra miles.
05
Best lakeside option
Pizza Cottage
Buckeye Lake Strip • Casual Lakeside Pizza Spot • Best For Groups And Day Trips
A roomy, laid-back shop near the water that’s ideal for big pies after a day at Buckeye Lake.
For Somerset residents making a day of it at Buckeye Lake, Pizza Cottage is an easy rally point for the whole crew. The menu leans broad—think specialty pies, shareable appetizers, and salads—but the sweet-leaning sauce and well-browned cheese are what keep people coming back. It’s especially handy for large groups, with plenty of space and pizzas sized to feed a crowd.