01
Best overall pick
Augie’s Pizza & Ribs – South Russell
South Russell Village • Old-School Pizza And Ribs Joint • Go-To Local Favorite
Classic pies, hearty portions, and a loyal following make Augie’s the default pizza call for much of South Russell.[3][4]
Augie’s has been feeding the South Russell and Chagrin Falls area for decades, and it shows in the steady traffic of regulars picking up family orders.[3][4] The menu leans comforting: generously topped pizzas with a slightly chewy crust, saucy ribs, and all the familiar sides you want for a low‑key night in. It’s especially strong for big family trays and game‑day spreads when you want plenty of food without fuss.[3]
02
Best pizza-and-pub combo
Crumb & Spigot
Chagrin Falls Village Center • Upscale Tavern With Craft Pizza • Best For Date Night
Crumb & Spigot pairs thoughtful, wood‑fired‑style pizzas with a polished tavern vibe and a solid drink list.[5]
Set just outside the waterfall bustle, Crumb & Spigot feels like the grown‑up option when you still want great pizza on the table.[5] The crusts lean artisan rather than greasy slice shop, with toppings that run from simple margherita to more cheffy combinations, all backed by a rotating craft beer and cocktail lineup. It’s an easy pick when you want to turn “let’s grab pizza” into a proper night out without driving far from South Russell.
03
Classic slice shop feel
Pizzeria DiLauro
Bainbridge–Chagrin Corridor • Family-Run New York–Style Pizzeria • Best For Classic Slices
Pizzeria DiLauro channels a traditional New York slice shop with foldable pies and a low‑key, neighborhood feel.[5]
A short hop from South Russell, Pizzeria DiLauro is the kind of place where the staff learns your usual and the pizza comes out hot and fast.[5] Expect thin, foldable slices, straightforward toppings, and a sauce‑to‑cheese balance that keeps locals coming back for quick dinners and takeout. It’s ideal when you want something unfussy, familiar, and reliably good after a long day on 422 or running errands nearby.
04
Carryout workhorse
Gionino’s Pizzeria – Chagrin Falls
Chagrin Falls Outskirts • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Delivery Nights
Gionino’s is a regional favorite for thickly topped pizzas, fried chicken, and fast, predictable delivery on busy weeknights.
For many South Russell households, Gionino’s is the weeknight workhorse: call it in, get a hot pizza and extras at the door, and dinner is solved. The dough is on the heartier side, the cheese pull is generous, and the topping options run deep enough to satisfy a crowd. Add in wings, jojo potatoes, and big salads, and it’s a one‑stop move when you’re feeding a mix of kids and adults without leaving the couch.
05
Most customizable pies
Master Pizza – Solon
Solon Retail Strip • Modern Takeout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Big Group Orders
Master Pizza in Solon offers highly customizable pies and specialty combinations that work well for mixed‑taste groups.
Just west of South Russell, the Solon Master Pizza location is handy when you’re already out near the big-box stores and want to bring something home. The menu is built for customization, from crust style and sauce to an unusually long list of toppings and specialty pies, so everyone in the group can get exactly what they want. It’s particularly useful for parties, office lunches, or team nights when you’re juggling multiple preferences and dietary quirks in one order.