01
Best overall pick
Donatos Pizza
North Bridge Street, Chillicothe • Ohio Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Crisp, edge-to-edge toppings and consistent pies make Donatos the most reliable all-around choice nearby.
If you’re after that classic Ohio thin crust with toppings spread right to the edge, Donatos on the north side of Chillicothe is hard to beat. It’s an easy jump from South Salem for carryout or delivery, with everything from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies. Add in salads and subs, and it works just as well for a quick dinner as it does for feeding a bigger crowd.
02
Best for delivery deals
Papa John’s Pizza
Western Avenue, Chillicothe • Delivery-Focused Chain Spot • Best For Delivery Deals
Papa John’s is the go-to when you want familiar pizzas, frequent specials, and straightforward delivery from Chillicothe out toward South Salem.
Located along the busy Western Avenue strip, this Papa John’s is set up for quick turnaround on delivery and carryout orders. The menu leans on big, saucy pies, stuffed crust options, and plenty of sides like breadsticks and wings. It’s especially handy on weeknights when you want to grab a deal, feed a few people, and skip cooking altogether.
03
Quick, customizable pies
Domino’s Pizza
East Main Street, Chillicothe • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Late-Night Standby
Domino’s is the flexible choice for fast, build-your-own pizzas and late-night cravings.
Domino’s in Chillicothe leans into speed and customization, with multiple crust options and an easy-to-mix list of toppings. It’s a smart pick if you’re heading back toward South Salem and want to grab a hot pie on the way. Between the pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, and desserts, everyone in the car can usually find something they’re happy with.
04
Sit-down chain classic
Pizza Hut
Downtown Chillicothe • Casual Dine-In Pizza Restaurant • Best For Families
Pizza Hut delivers that familiar pan-pizza comfort with room to sit down and linger over a meal.
For families making the short drive in from South Salem, Pizza Hut offers a straightforward dine-in option with plenty of seating. Thick, buttery pan pizzas and stuffed-crust pies share the menu with wings, pasta, and a few kid-friendly choices. It’s the kind of place where you can stretch out after a game or school event and let everyone refuel without rushing.
05
Fast and affordable
Little Caesars Pizza
Us-23 Retail Corridor, Chillicothe • Grab-And-Go Value Pizza Shop • Best On A Budget
Little Caesars is ideal when you want hot, ready-made pizzas at a price that makes feeding a group painless.
Just off the main highway into Chillicothe, Little Caesars is built for speed and value rather than lingering. The Hot-N-Ready pies are handy when you’re driving back toward South Salem and need something you can pick up without a long wait. It’s a practical choice for kids’ sleepovers, last-minute team dinners, or any night when cost and convenience matter more than lingering over the menu.