01
Best for big groups
Marion's Piazza
North Springfield Shopping Corridor • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Party-Friendly Classic
A roomy, old-school spot known for cracker-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and easy seating for big parties.
About 15 minutes west of South Vienna, Marion's is the go-to when you’re feeding a crowd and want everyone to leave happy. Pizzas arrive on metal trays with a super-thin, crispy crust cut into small squares, perfect for sharing around a big table. Pair a deluxe or pepperoni pie with a pitcher of soda and you’ve got a simple, nostalgic night out.
02
Best local institution
The Hickory Inn
North Limestone Near Wittenberg • Family Tavern With Classic Pan Pizzas • Old-School Sit-Down Pick
A long-running Springfield favorite where cozy booths, pan-style pies, and friendly service keep locals coming back.
The Hickory Inn feels like the kind of place families in Springfield have been going to for decades, and many of them have. The pizza leans toward a heartier, pan-style crust with plenty of cheese and toppings, and the menu backs it up with wings and sandwiches if you’re feeding a mixed group. It’s an easy choice when you want a relaxed dinner after a day on the road or at nearby Wittenberg University.
03
Best neighborhood slice vibe
Bada Bing! Pizzeria
Near Downtown Springfield • New York-Leaning Neighborhood Pizzeria • Casual Slice And Carryout Spot
A laid-back shop turning out foldable slices and build-your-own pies with plenty of topping options.
If you like a slightly thinner, foldable slice with a bit of chew, Bada Bing! is worth the quick drive into Springfield. The menu is straightforward—think classic cheese, pepperoni, and specialty combos—but the crust and sauce have enough character to stand out from the chains. It’s a smart stop for a quick lunch, game-day pickup, or a low-key evening where you’re grabbing pizza to bring back to South Vienna.
04
Best for consistent delivery
Donatos Pizza (Springfield)
East Springfield • Ohio Chain Known For Edge-To-Edge Toppings • Reliable Delivery Favorite
A regional chain that wins points for its crispy thin crust, tidy square cuts, and generous topping coverage.
Donatos is a familiar name across Ohio, and the Springfield location is a convenient option when you want predictable, quick pizza without driving far. The thin crust is crisp and light, with toppings spread from edge to edge so every square-cut piece feels like a “good slice.” It’s especially handy for delivery back toward South Vienna when you’d rather stay in than dine out.
05
Best small-town classic
Ronettis Pizza
Downtown London • Old-School Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Worth-The-Drive Hometown Favorite
A long-running London pizza shop with a nostalgic dining room and generously topped pies that taste like true hometown fare.
Head about 20 minutes east to London and you’ll find Ronettis, the kind of place where locals have ‘their’ order and stick with it for years. The pizza comes with a slightly thicker crust, plenty of cheese, and a sauce that leans comforting rather than flashy. It’s a fun detour when you want to explore beyond Springfield and see where nearby towns go for their Friday night pizza fix.