01
Best overall pick
Giovanni's Pizza
South Webster Village Center • Classic Small-Town Pizza Shop • Hometown Standby
A reliable South Webster staple turning out hearty, cheese-loaded pies that locals grow up on.
Giovanni's in South Webster is the spot most residents point to first when you ask about pizza. The crust is on the thicker side but still soft, built to hold a heavy layer of cheese and toppings without getting soggy. It is a natural choice for Friday night carryout, team parties, and those nights when you want leftovers for lunch the next day.
02
Best for sharing with a crowd
Giovanni's Pizza
Along Us‑23 In Lucasville • Family-Friendly Regional Pizzeria • Game-Night Favorite
Big, crowd-pleasing pizzas and familiar sides make the Lucasville Giovanni's ideal for feeding a group.
The Lucasville outpost of Giovanni's gives South Webster folks another dependable option just up the road. Pies here are generous, with plenty of edge-to-edge toppings and classic combinations that satisfy mixed groups. Pair a couple of large pizzas with wings and breadsticks and you are set for a Buckeyes game or a family get-together.
03
Best for families
LaRosa's Pizzeria
Portsmouth East End • Sit-Down Family Pizzeria • Best For Dine-In Meals
A family-oriented spot where you can linger over Cincinnati-style pies, pasta, and salads.
LaRosa's in Portsmouth brings a fuller dine-in experience compared with many carryout-focused shops around Scioto County. The menu goes beyond pizza, but the pies stand out for their slightly sweet sauce and customizable crust and topping options. It is a good choice when you want to sit down, let the kids spread out, and not feel rushed through your meal.
04
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Downtown Portsmouth • National Delivery-Focused Chain • Fastest Delivery Bet
Domino's is the go-to when you want a hot pizza at your door quickly, with plenty of crust and topping options.
While it is a national name, the Portsmouth Domino's plays an important role for South Webster residents who do not mind a short drive or are inside the delivery range. The menu covers everything from hand-tossed to pan and thin crust, plus wings, sandwiches, and desserts for a one-stop order. It is especially handy for late study sessions, impromptu hangouts, or nights when cooking is off the table.
05
Best value combo deals
Pizza Hut
New Boston Retail Strip • Casual Chain Pizzeria With Buffet Vibes • Best Value For Big Appetites
Stuffed crust, classic pan pies, and frequent specials make this Pizza Hut a budget-friendly option for hungry groups.
The New Boston Pizza Hut is a familiar stop for Scioto County shoppers looking to refuel after a run through the big-box stores. The hallmark here is consistency: thick, buttery pan crusts, customizable topping mixes, and deals that make feeding a family or team fairly painless. If you like to mix pizza with breadsticks, wings, and maybe a dessert pizza, this is an easy all-in-one choice.