01
Best overall pick
Highland Pizza & Ice Cream
Marengo • Small-Town Pizza And Ice Cream Parlor • Local Go-To For All-Ages
A friendly Marengo staple serving crowd-pleasing pizzas alongside soft-serve and scooped ice cream.
Just west of Sparta in Marengo, Highland Pizza & Ice Cream feels like the classic small-town spot where everyone eventually ends up. The pizzas lean hearty and saucy, with familiar toppings and plenty of cheese, and you can follow your pie with a cone or sundae without changing venues. It’s an easy pick when you want something reliable that works for kids, grandparents, and everyone in between.
02
Best sit-down outing
Pizza Hut
Downtown Mount Gilead • Family-Friendly Dine-In Chain • Classic Booth-And-Pitcher Experience
A familiar red-roof standby where Mount Gilead families gather for pan pizza, breadsticks, and big soda pitchers.
For Sparta residents who grew up on chain pizza nights, the Pizza Hut in Mount Gilead hits that exact nostalgia note. The dining room setup makes it easy to linger over a pan or hand-tossed pie, and the menu is predictable in the best way—breadsticks, wings, and all the usual topping combos. It’s a solid choice when you want an easy group meal without overthinking it.
03
Top takeout option
Domino’s Pizza
West Mount Gilead • Carryout And Delivery Chain Shop • Fast And Customizable
A quick-hit choice for fully customizable pizzas, sides, and late-evening cravings out of Mount Gilead.
When convenience matters more than atmosphere, the Domino’s in Mount Gilead is usually the easiest play from Sparta. Online ordering, frequent deals, and a deep roster of sauces and toppings make it simple to keep a crowd fed on a budget. It’s especially handy on busy weeknights or game days when you just want hot pizza ready on time with no surprises.
04
Best game-day stop
Donatos Pizza
Sunbury Town Center • Thin-Crust Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Crispy-Edge Crowd-Pleaser
Sunbury’s Donatos dishes out signature thin-crust pies loaded edge-to-edge with toppings.
If you don’t mind a bit more of a drive, Donatos in Sunbury rewards you with that distinctly Ohio thin crust and “edge-to-edge” topping style. The pepperoni and deluxe combinations are especially popular for sharing, since every slice gets a fair share of toppings. Pair a couple of larges with salads and wings and you’ve got an easy spread for watching the Buckeyes or hosting friends.
05
Worth-the-drive pick
Amato’s Woodfired Pizza
Historic Downtown Delaware • Upscale Wood-Fired Pizza Bar • Best For Date Night
A wood-fired favorite in downtown Delaware with blistered crusts, thoughtful toppings, and a cozy bar vibe.
For a night that feels more like an evening out than a quick bite, Amato’s in downtown Delaware is the standout within range of Sparta. Pizzas come out of the wood-fired oven with leopard-spotted crusts and toppings that go beyond basic pepperoni, including seasonal vegetables and specialty cheeses. It’s a great choice when you’re willing to drive a bit farther for better ingredients, a glass of wine or craft beer, and a livelier atmosphere.