01
Best overall pick
Romeo's Pizza – Medina
Medina Public Square • Local Ohio-Style Chain • Local Favorite
A Medina-born chain known for its sweet-leaning sauce, creative specialty pies, and reliably generous toppings.
Romeo’s is the spot locals point to when they want pizza that feels a notch above typical delivery chains. The crust is sturdy enough for loaded specialty pies, and the sweeter red sauce gives everything a distinct Ohio twist. It’s an easy choice when you’re in Medina anyway and want to bring a couple of hot pizzas back to Spencer.
02
Best for classic pies
Master Pizza – Medina
North Court Street Corridor • Classic Thin-Crust Shop • Old-School Pick
Thin, edge-to-edge pizzas with plenty of cheese and toppings give this long-running Ohio brand a nostalgic, old-school feel.
Master Pizza leans into a classic, square-cut style that’s all about crisp crust and balanced toppings. The menu covers the basics well, but there are also plenty of build-your-own options if your group has strong opinions. It’s a solid choice when you’re craving straightforward, no-fuss pizza after a day out around Medina.
03
Best pizza-and-more option
Geppetto's Pizza & Ribs – Medina
South Medina • Pizza And Ribs Joint • Best For Big Appetites
Hearty pizzas, meaty ribs, and classic sides make this an easy pick when you need more than just a couple of pies.
Geppetto’s is the place to call when your crew wants pizza but also wings, ribs, and plenty of extras. The pizzas come piled with toppings and pair well with their sauces and sides, so it’s ideal for casual gatherings or game days. Order a mix of pies and ribs, then head back toward Spencer with a full takeout haul.
04
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza – Medina (N Court St)
North Medina Retail Strip • National Delivery Chain • Best For Delivery
Fast, consistent delivery and customizable crusts make this Domino’s a dependable option for spur-of-the-moment pizza nights.
When convenience matters most, the Medina Domino’s is the go-to for many Spencer households. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to time a pickup run or have a driver meet you closer to home. With familiar toppings, stuffed crusts, and plenty of sides, it’s a low-stress solution for busy weeknights.
05
Best value pick
Marco's Pizza – Medina
East Medina • Carryout-Focused Pizzeria • Best Value Combo Deals
Saucy, crowd-pleasing pies and frequent specials make Marco’s a smart choice when you’re feeding a group on a budget.
Marco’s leans into big-flavor, comfort-style pizza with plenty of cheese and toppings, plus regular coupons and bundle deals. The menu spans classic pepperoni, specialty pies, subs, and salads, so everyone can find something without overcomplicating the order. It’s a practical stop on your way back toward Spencer when you want maximum food for the money.