01
Best overall pick
Valley Pizza Co
In The Heart Of Spring Valley • Small-Town Carryout Shop • Local Favorite
A cozy village spot turning out well-topped, no-fuss pies that feel made for a Friday night at home.
Valley Pizza Co is the kind of low-key place where the staff knows regulars by name and the pizza boxes often head straight to local porches and picnic tables. Expect classic topping combos, a nicely browned crust, and portions that suit hungry families and trail riders alike. Call ahead on busy evenings; the small operation can get slammed when the village is buzzing.
02
Best for crispy thin crust
Donatos Pizza
Xenia, About 10 Minutes North • Ohio-Style Thin-Crust Chain • Reliable Weeknight Option
Edge-to-edge toppings on a crackery thin crust make this Xenia outpost a dependable choice when you want dinner sorted fast.
The Xenia Donatos is a go-to for fans of ultra-thin, square-cut pies loaded all the way to the rim. It’s especially handy when you’re feeding a crowd, thanks to consistent timing, online ordering, and big party orders that tend to arrive right on schedule. Pair a couple of signature pizzas with a salad or wings and you’ve got an easy solution after kids’ practices or a late workday.
03
Best Dayton-style classic
Cassano's Pizza King
Central Xenia • Old-School Dayton-Style Pizzeria • Nostalgic Pick
Paper-thin crust, square slices, and a salty-savory bite give this long-running local chain its loyal following.
Cassano’s in Xenia leans into the classic Dayton-style formula: a super-thin crust, a generous sprinkle of toppings, and that unmistakable old-school flavor. Locals who grew up on Cassano’s still stop in for carryout when cravings hit, often ordering a couple of large pizzas to share. If you want a taste of regional pizza history without driving into Dayton proper, this is a satisfying shortcut.
04
Best for big groups
Marion's Piazza
Beavercreek, Near Fairfield Commons • Large, Family-Friendly Piazza • Group Gathering Spot
A Dayton-area institution with sprawling dining rooms, party-ready pies, and a lively, throwback atmosphere.
Marion’s Piazza in Beavercreek is worth the extra drive when you’re hosting a team celebration, birthday, or multi-family outing. The pizzas arrive on big trays, cut into small squares that make it easy for everyone to sample different toppings. With plenty of seating and a casual, bustling vibe, it’s the kind of place where no one worries about kids being a little loud or grabbing one more slice.
05
Best for families
LaRosa's Pizzeria
Centerville, Along Oh-48 • Cincinnati-Style Family Pizzeria • Sit-Down Family Choice
Comforting pies with a slightly thicker crust and sweet-leaning sauce make this a hit with kids and parents alike.
LaRosa’s in Centerville brings a Cincinnati favorite within easy reach of Spring Valley, with a menu geared toward family dinners and relaxed nights out. The crust runs a bit thicker than the Dayton-style spots, and the sauce has a touch of sweetness that pairs well with classic pepperoni or heavier specialty combinations. Booths, kids’ options, and plenty of shareable appetizers make it an easy crowd-pleaser when you want to linger over pizza instead of rushing home.