01
Best overall pick
Roma's Pizza & Pasta
West Central Avenue Corridor • Family-Run Italian Pizzeria And Pasta House • Local Favorite For Sit-Down Pies
A cozy, family-owned spot where classic, generously topped pies share the menu with red-sauce comfort staples.
Roma’s feels like the place Springboro residents recommend when someone asks for a proper sit-down pizza dinner. The crust leans classic American—sturdy enough for plenty of toppings but not overly heavy—and the sauce has that slightly sweet, slow-simmered profile that works well with pepperoni or simple cheese. It’s also a good pick when some in your group want pizza and others are craving baked pasta, garlic knots, or a hearty Italian entrée.
02
Best for Dayton-style squares
Cassano's Pizza King
South Springboro / Dayton Corridor • Old-School Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Classic Regional Choice
Ultra-thin, crispy-crust pizza cut into squares, with a nostalgic Dayton-area feel.
Cassano’s is where you go if you want that signature, cracker-thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings that Dayton-area pizza is known for. The pies are cut into small squares, making them easy to share with a group or pick at over a game on TV. It’s more of a casual, grab-a-box-and-go kind of place, and locals tend to have strong, loyal opinions about their favorite topping combinations here.
03
Best for crispy edge-to-edge pepperoni
Donatos Pizza
Main Retail Strip • Fast-Casual Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Crowd-Pleaser
Known for its thin crust covered corner-to-corner in pepperoni, Donatos hits the spot when you need predictable, shareable pizza fast.
If you like a slightly sturdier thin crust with toppings all the way to the edge, Donatos is a safe bet. The classic pepperoni—loaded with those little crispy-edged rounds—is the go-to order, but they also do well with lighter veggie combos and simple cheese pies for kids. It’s an easy option for weeknight dinners, office lunches, or feeding a team without overthinking the order.
04
Best for Detroit-style deep dish
Jet's Pizza
Central Springboro • Detroit-Style And Hand-Tossed Pizzeria • Hearty Takeout Pick
Thick, airy Detroit-style squares with caramelized cheese edges make Jet’s the choice when you want a heavier, comfort-food kind of pizza night.
Jet’s is all about that pan-baked, rectangular crust that’s crisp on the outside and soft inside, with cheese that caramelizes along the edges. The signature Detroit-style pies are rich and filling, especially with bold toppings like spicy pepperoni or sausage. If you’re feeding serious appetites or want leftovers that reheat well the next day, this is the box to bring home.
05
Best late-night option
Papa Johns Pizza
West Central Avenue Strip • National Delivery-Focused Pizza Shop • Go-To For Late Deliveries And Big Groups
Familiar, soft-crust pies with plenty of sauces and sides, ideal when convenience and delivery hours matter most.
Papa Johns isn’t trying to be a hidden gem; it’s the backup plan that often becomes the main plan because it’s open, fast, and easy to customize. The crust is soft and slightly chewy, with a sweeter red sauce and plenty of topping choices to keep everyone at the table happy. Add-ons like garlic knots, breadsticks, and extra dipping sauces make it especially handy for parties, movie nights, or last-minute gatherings.