01
Best old-school pick
Catanzaro's Pizza & Subs
South Springfield • Old-School Pizza And Sub Shop • Local Legend
A no-frills staple turning out square-cut pies and subs that taste like Springfield nostalgia.
Catanzaro's is the kind of place where the staff recognizes regulars and the pizza comes piled with toppings edge to edge. The crust is classic Springfield tavern-style: thin, crispy, and cut into squares, perfect for sharing around a crowded table. It's an easy choice when you want something familiar and reliably good without overthinking it.
02
Best late-night option
Cousin Vinny's Pizza
North Springfield • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Late-Night Standby
Hearty, affordable pies and wings that hit the spot when it's late and you're hungry.
Cousin Vinny's leans into big-flavor, big-value pizzas that are easy to split with a group or stretch over a couple of meals. It's especially popular with students and late-shift workers thanks to generous specials and hours that run later than many local spots. If you want something fast, filling, and delivered without fuss, this is the go-to.
03
Best for creative toppings
Romeo's Pizza
East Main Street Corridor • Modern Takeout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Adventurous Eaters
Handcrafted pies with bolder sauces and topping combos than your average chain.
Romeo's brings a more contemporary feel to Springfield's pizza mix, with sweeter signature sauces and toppings that go beyond the usual pepperoni-and-mushroom routine. It's a strong choice when one person wants a loaded specialty pie while someone else sticks to a simple cheese or pepperoni. Order ahead for pickup or delivery and you've got an easy crowd-pleaser for game night or a busy weeknight.
04
Best family sit-down spot
Hickory Inn
North Side • Family-Friendly Tavern With Pizza And Comfort Food • Best For Families
A long-running Springfield hangout known for thin-crust pizza, booths, and a relaxed, everyone’s-welcome vibe.
Hickory Inn feels like the kind of neighborhood spot every town wishes it had: roomy booths, a laid-back bar area, and plenty of menu options for picky eaters. The pizza is a highlight, with a thin, crisp crust and a sauce that keeps locals coming back decade after decade. It's an easy pick when you want to sit down, linger over a pitcher, and let the kids split a large pie at the table.
05
Best value slices
Mikey's Pizza
Downtown-Adjacent • Casual Neighborhood Slice Shop • Budget-Friendly Pick
Straightforward, satisfying pizza that’s kind to your wallet and great for grab-and-go.
Mikey's keeps things simple: friendly counter service, classic topping choices, and prices that make it easy to feed a couple of people on a tight budget. It's the sort of spot locals swing by on the way home or between errands for a quick pie or a few slices. If you're nearby and craving a low-key, no-drama pizza fix, this is a solid move.