01
Best overall pick
Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap
Newark – East Side • Wood-Fired Kitchen And Taproom • Best For Lingering With A Pint
A lively spot pairing blistered wood-fired pizzas with a strong craft beer lineup.
If you want a night out rather than just a box on the counter, Elliot's is worth the short drive from St. Louisville. The crust comes out with just the right char, topped with ingredient combinations that feel creative without being fussy. Grab a seat, order a pie and a pint, and treat it like your go-to Friday night destination.
02
Closest classic
Cristy's Pizza
Utica Village Center • Classic Carryout And Delivery Shop • Weeknight Family Standby
A small-town pizza counter known for generous toppings and dependable takeout.
Cristy's in Utica is one of the quickest options when you're heading north or already out on errands. The pies lean classic Midwestern—plenty of cheese, a sturdy crust, and toppings that actually cover the whole slice. It’s the kind of place locals program into their phones for last-minute family dinners and game nights.
03
Old-school favorite
Plaza Pizza
Downtown Newark • Old-School Neighborhood Pizzeria • Go-To For Loaded Specialty Pies
A long-running Newark staple dishing out saucy, cheese-heavy pies with a loyal local following.
Plaza Pizza has the slightly nostalgic feel of the pizza you grew up with, right down to the cozy, no-frills vibe. The crust holds up under serious amounts of cheese and toppings, making their specialty combinations an easy choice. It’s a smart stop if you’re already in downtown Newark and want something hearty before or after errands on the square.
04
Best for sharing
Donatos Pizza
Newark – North 21St Street Corridor • Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Pick For Big Groups
Crispy edge-to-edge thin crust and precise square-cut slices make feeding a crowd straightforward.
When you’ve got a lot of people to feed back in St. Louisville, Donatos is a low-stress option. The thin crust and edge-to-edge topping style mean every slice feels like a corner piece, which is handy when you’re splitting pies across a table. Order a mix of classics and a loaded specialty or two and you’re set for parties, work nights, or team celebrations.
05
Most convenient delivery
Papa Johns Pizza
Newark – West Side • National Delivery Chain Outpost • Late-Night Delivery Choice
A familiar national name that’s handy when you want predictable pies and flexible delivery hours.
For those evenings when you don’t want to think too hard, Papa Johns keeps things simple and consistent. The menu is broad enough that everyone in the house can find something, from classic pepperoni to stuffed crust and breadsticks. It’s especially useful if you’re looking for a place that can reliably handle later-night orders after a long day.