01
Classic local institution
Coccia House
Downtown Wooster • Old-School Tavern-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Loaded Pies
A Wooster landmark turning out decked-out pizzas with a loyal following and a lively, slightly time-warped dining room.
For many Wayne County locals, Coccia House is the default answer when someone asks where to go for pizza. Expect thick, edge-to-edge toppings, a mildly sweet sauce, and a crust that holds up under the weight. The dining room gets busy on weekends, so plan on a wait or order ahead for carryout if you are driving up from Sterling.
02
Best for groups and variety
East of Chicago Pizza
North Side Wooster • Casual Buffet-Style Pizzeria • Best For Families And Groups
A flexible spot for thick-crust, pan, and specialty pizzas, with family-friendly combos and frequent deals.
East of Chicago’s Wooster location is a solid pick when you need to feed a mixed crowd without overthinking it. Their signature pan and deep-dish styles are hearty, and the menu runs wide with wings, subs, and a salad bar depending on the time of day. It is an easy stop if you are already in Wooster for errands and want a laid-back, everyone’s-happy pizza option.
03
Takeout staple to the north
Gionino's Pizzeria
Wadsworth • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Big-Topping Carryout
Akron-area chain known for generous cheese, bold toppings, and the bonus of fried chicken and JoJo potatoes.
If you are up toward Wadsworth, Gionino’s is a dependable call-ahead stop on the way back to Sterling. Pizzas come piled high, with a crust sturdy enough for road-trip slices, and the menu’s fried chicken and JoJos make it easy to turn dinner into a full spread. It is more of a grab-and-go operation than a sit-down spot, which suits busy weeknights and game days.
04
Most reliable late-night option
Domino's Pizza
Wooster • National Delivery Chain • Best For Fast Delivery And Custom Orders
A go-to for quick, customizable pizzas and sides that will deliver out toward Sterling’s back roads when others are closed.
While it is not a mom-and-pop shop, the Wooster Domino’s earns its place on the list for sheer reliability and reach. The online ordering and tracking are convenient if you are out in the country and just want something hot without a long drive. Use it when timing matters more than ambiance and you want predictable, made-to-order pies and bread sides.
05
Worth-the-drive legend
Luigi's Restaurant
Downtown Akron • Historic Italian-American Pizza Parlor • Destination Pick For Classic Pies
An old-school Akron icon with chewy, cheesy pies and a no-frills, always-busy dining room that feels frozen in time.
When you are up for a longer outing, Luigi’s is the kind of place many northeast Ohioans will happily drive for. The pizzas are straightforward but memorable, with plenty of cheese and a crust that strikes a balance between crisp and chewy. Expect a line at peak times, bring cash, and treat it as a little pizza pilgrimage from Sterling rather than a quick bite.