01
Best overall pick
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek • Modern Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Destination-Worthy Pies
A busy, polished spot in Sugarcreek turning out crisp, creative pies that feel special without being fussy.
Park Street Pizza is the place locals point to when they want to prove small-town pizza can hang with the big cities. The dough has a light char and chew, toppings lean seasonal and thoughtful, and the menu stretches from classic pepperoni to farm-style combinations. It’s worth planning a night out here rather than just a quick grab-and-go stop.
02
Classic hometown slice
Penso's Pizza
Gnadenhutten • Old-School Takeout Shop • Local Favorite
A longtime Tuscarawas County staple known for its generous cheese, sturdy crust, and straight-ahead, no-gimmick pies.
If you grew up anywhere around Gnadenhutten, there’s a good chance Penso’s was your Friday-night pizza. The crust is on the thicker side with plenty of cheese, and the toppings skew classic—think pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms rather than wild experiments. Call ahead, pick it up, and you’ve got exactly the kind of comforting pizza that travels well back to Stone Creek.
03
Best for sit-down dinners
Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House
Dennison • Family Italian Restaurant • Best For Families
A family-run Italian spot where thin, saucy pizza shares the spotlight with big plates of pasta and baskets of garlic bread.
Pangrazio’s is where you go when you want pizza but also need a proper sit-down meal. The pies come with a slightly crisp crust and a tangy sauce that pairs nicely with a salad or a plate of spaghetti for the table. It’s a relaxed, family-friendly choice when you’ve got a mix of pizza purists and pasta fans to keep happy.
04
Best for custom builds
East of Chicago Pizza
Newcomerstown • Casual Regional Chain • Build-Your-Own Favorite
A flexible option where you can choose your crust style, load up toppings, and feed a crowd without much planning.
East of Chicago in Newcomerstown leans into variety, offering everything from pan and traditional to thin crust, plus a long list of toppings. It’s especially handy when you have a group coming in from different directions around Stone Creek and need something everyone can agree on. Grab a couple of specialty pizzas and some cheesy bread, and you’re set for game night or a cabin weekend.
05
Reliable late-night pick
Domino's Pizza
New Philadelphia • Fast-Delivery Chain • Late-Night And Last-Minute
A convenient option in New Philadelphia when you need hot pizza on the table quickly, especially later in the evening.
Domino’s in New Philadelphia is less about ambiance and more about timing and consistency. The menu is familiar—hand-tossed, pan, or thin crust with all the standard toppings, plus wings and pastas if you want to bulk out the order. When every other kitchen is closing and you’re still on the road near Stone Creek, this is the dependable fallback that gets the job done.