01
Best overall pick
Kraus' Pizza Strasburg
South Wooster Corridor • Classic Ohio-Style Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A hometown Kraus' location turning out consistently crisp, cheesy pies that Strasburg residents swear by.
Tucked along South Wooster, the Strasburg outpost of Kraus' feels like the small-town pizza shop every village wishes it had. The menu leans classic—pepperoni, sausage, and lots of cheese—on a slightly crisp crust with that nostalgic Ohio tavern-style feel. Call ahead on busy evenings; regulars know this is the go-to spot for ballgame nights and low-key family dinners.
02
Best in-village dine-in
Penso's Pizza
North Wooster Strip • Casual Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Best For Families
Laid-back spot in the heart of town for hearty pizzas, subs, and a relaxed sit-down meal.
Just up North Wooster Avenue from the center of Strasburg, Penso's is the kind of place where staff recognize regulars and kids get a say in the toppings. Pies are generous and comforting, with plenty of cheese, classic toppings, and a crust that holds up well for leftovers. It’s an easy choice when you want to linger over a pizza and a few sides instead of rushing home with a box.
03
Worth-the-drive destination
Park Street Pizza
Downtown Sugarcreek • Farm-To-Table Style Pizzeria • Best For Food-Focused Night Out
A lively, from-scratch pizzeria in Sugarcreek that’s become a regional draw for creative, quality pies.
About a short country drive from Strasburg, Park Street Pizza in Sugarcreek is often the first place locals recommend when you’re willing to go a bit farther for dinner. Expect thoughtfully sourced ingredients, seasonal specials, and toppings that go beyond the usual pepperoni-and-mushroom lineup. The dining room has a buzzy, modern small-town feel, making it a great choice for casual date nights or meeting friends halfway.
04
Classic Italian option
Mario's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
North Dover • Family-Run Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Sit-Down Italian And Pizza
Old-school Italian restaurant in Dover where the pizza is as much a draw as the pasta.
Head up to Dover when you want pizza with a side of red-sauce comfort. Mario's has the feel of a long-running family spot, with a menu that spans baked pastas, subs, and generously topped pizzas. The pies come with a slightly thicker, chewy crust and a hearty layer of cheese, making this a solid pick when your group can’t decide between ‘pizza place’ and ‘Italian restaurant.’
05
Craft beer and pizza combo
Sammy Sue's BBQ & Pizza
Downtown Dover • Casual Bar-And-Pizza Spot • Best For Groups
Dover hangout pairing house-made pizzas with a strong lineup of drinks and casual bar food.
If you’re meeting friends from around the county, Sammy Sue’s in downtown Dover hits the sweet spot between casual bar and pizza joint. Their pizzas share the menu with barbecue and other pub favorites, so there’s something for everyone at the table. It’s a good match when you want to watch a game, try a few beers, and still end up with a solid pie in front of you.