01
Essential local classic
DiCarlo's Original Pizza
Downtown Steubenville • Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Local Favorite For Classic Slices
The birthplace of Ohio Valley-style pizza, serving square pan pies topped with a blanket of cold cheese on hot crust.
If you ask around for the most iconic pizza near Stratton, DiCarlo's is the name you will hear first. The menu is stripped-down simple—sauce, crust, cheese, a handful of toppings—and everything is built around that signature hot-and-cold bite. It is a grab-and-go kind of place, so plan on carryout and enjoy it while the crust is still crackling.
02
Best for feeding a crowd
Giannamore's Pizza
West Of Steubenville Near Pottery Addition • Family-Run Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Game Nights
Old-school sheet pizzas with generous toppings and a loyal local following.
Giannamore's is the kind of place where people order the same sheet pizza for every birthday, tailgate, and Friday night in. The crust is sturdy enough to handle plenty of toppings, and the edge pieces have just the right crunch. Call ahead if you are coming from Stratton and need a full sheet for a crowd—the kitchen can get busy on weekends.
03
Closest everyday option
Ray's Pizza
Toronto Riverfront • Casual Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best Nearby Option To Stratton
Straightforward pies and subs that make an easy stop just up the road from Stratton.
Ray's is a go-to for Stratton residents who want pizza without driving all the way into Steubenville. Expect classic crust, familiar toppings, and the kind of menu where everyone can find something, from basic cheese to loaded meat combinations. It is a low-key, reliable choice for a quick pickup on your way home along the river.
04
Best sit-down experience
Naples Spaghetti House
North End Steubenville • Old-School Italian Restaurant • Best For Family Dinners
A vintage red-sauce institution where pizza shares the stage with big plates of pasta.
For a proper sit-down meal rather than a quick box of slices, Naples Spaghetti House is hard to beat. The pizzas lean classic—think substantial crust, plenty of cheese, and familiar toppings—served alongside house-made sauces and old-fashioned booths. It is a comfortable place to bring family or out-of-town visitors when you want both pizza and a little local history in the same stop.
05
Reliable late-night pick
Domino's Pizza
Near Franciscan University In Steubenville • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Fast, predictable pizza and sides with the convenience of app-based ordering and delivery up the river.
When it is late, the weather is rough, or you just want something familiar brought to your door, the Steubenville Domino's is the practical choice. The menu covers all the chain standards—custom pizzas, wings, bread twists, and desserts—so groups can mix and match easily. It is especially handy for visitors staying in rentals near Stratton who want straightforward delivery without a drive.