01
Classic local legend
The Elmton
5Th Street Neighborhood • Classic Tavern-Style Pizzeria And Bar • Local Legend
Crispy, square-cut bar pizza and a comfortable, lived-in dining room make The Elmton a must-visit Struthers staple.
If you ask longtime residents where to start with Struthers pizza, The Elmton is the name that comes up first. The crust runs crisp at the edges with plenty of cheese and toppings, and it’s the kind of pizza that pairs perfectly with a cold drink in the cozy bar room. Go early on weekend nights—both the dining room and the takeout line fill up fast.
02
Best for families and big orders
Belleria Struthers
Youngstown-Poland Road Corridor • Family-Style Italian Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Parties
Belleria Struthers serves hearty, saucy pies and sheet pizzas that are built for sharing with a crowd.
This outpost of the local Belleria chain leans into generous portions, from thick, cheesy sheet pizzas to loaded specialty pies. The sauce is on the richer, slightly sweet side, which works well with classic toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and banana peppers. It’s a go-to for team parties, family gatherings, and any night when feeding a lot of people beats fussing over the oven at home.
03
Cozy bistro pick
St A's Bistro
Near Downtown Struthers • Casual Bistro With Creative Pies • Best For Date Night Or Lingered Meals
St A's Bistro combines well-crafted pizzas with a small, relaxed dining room that encourages you to stay for another slice.
While it feels more like a neighborhood bistro than a classic pizza joint, St A's turns out thoughtfully topped pies with a nicely baked crust. The menu usually includes a mix of safe favorites—think pepperoni and three-cheese—and a few more inventive combinations for when you want to branch out. It’s a strong choice when you want pizza but also a sit-down meal with a slower pace.
04
Brier Hill style specialist
Brier Hill Pizza & Wings
Lowellville Road Hilltop • Carryout Shop Specializing In Brier Hill Pizza • Go-To Carryout And Take-Home Trays
This small shop leans into the Mahoning Valley’s Brier Hill tradition, with thick, saucy trays that travel well and feed a group.
If you want to taste a hometown style, Brier Hill Pizza & Wings is the most direct route. Their namesake pizza typically comes as a pan-baked tray with a sturdy crust, plenty of tomato sauce, Romano-style cheese, and a scattering of peppers. It’s carryout-only, so call ahead, grab a couple of trays and wings, and you’re set for the game or a low-key night in.
05
Game-day favorite
La Villa Sports Bar and Grille
Riverside Neighborhood • Lively Sports Bar With A Strong Pizza Menu • Game-Day And Late-Night Pick
La Villa pairs a full sports-bar atmosphere with sturdy, shareable pizzas that hold up through a full game on the big screens.
Screens on every wall and a relaxed crowd give La Villa its energy, but the pizza keeps people ordering another round. Crusts are substantial enough to handle plenty of toppings, from extra pepperoni to loaded meat combos, making it easy to split a couple of pies with a table of friends. It’s the place to go when you want to watch the score, grab wings, and still make sure the pizza is more than an afterthought.