01
Best overall pick
Pizza Crossing
Downtown Logan • Bustling Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Go-To Favorite For Big Flavor And Big Groups
Generous toppings, a crispy-chewy crust, and lively small-town energy make Pizza Crossing in Logan the first place many Sugar Grove locals think of for pizza night.
Expect big, shareable pies with plenty of cheese, a slightly sweet sauce, and toppings that run all the way to the edge. The dining room is simple but always busy with teams, families, and friends grabbing buckets of pop and a couple of specialty pizzas. It is an easy after-hike stop if you have been exploring nearby Hocking Hills.
02
Worth-the-drive classic
Pizza Crossing
Tiki Lane, Lancaster • Family-Friendly Dine-In And Carryout Spot • Best For Sharing Pizzas After Errands In Town
The Lancaster outpost of Pizza Crossing delivers the same edge-to-edge, loaded pies in a slightly calmer, suburban setting.
This location is a convenient choice when you are already in Lancaster for shopping or a movie and want to bring dinner back toward Sugar Grove. Pizzas are hearty and consistent, with plenty of styles from classic pepperoni to loaded deluxe. The carryout operation is efficient, so call ahead, swing through, and you are back on the road in minutes.
03
Game-night standby
Cristy's Pizza
South Logan • Regional Pizza Chain With A Local Feel • Best For Delivery And Carryout
Cristy's in Logan leans into reliable, comfort-style pies that are ideal for delivery to a cabin or a casual night in.
The crust here is on the thinner, crisp side, with a classic Ohio balance of cheese and sauce that works well for both meat-heavy and veggie orders. Specials and combo deals make it a smart option when you are feeding a crowd on a budget. Many locals keep Cristy's on speed dial for Friday nights and big games.
04
Flexible crowd-pleaser
Cristy's Pizza
North Lancaster • Casual Counter-Service Pizza Shop • Easy Choice For Mixed Groups And Families
Cristy's Lancaster location offers the same familiar pies plus subs, salads, and sides, making it an easy win when everyone wants something a little different.
You order at the counter, then decide whether to eat in the simple dining area or haul everything back home toward Sugar Grove. The menu is broad without feeling overwhelming, so you can mix a classic pepperoni with a white pizza and some wings and know everyone will find something. It is especially handy for quick weeknight takeout on the way back from Lancaster.
05
Hidden resort gem
The Lodge at Hide-A-Way Hills
Hide-A-Way Hills Community South Of Sugar Grove • Rustic Private-Club Restaurant With A Pizza Focus • Best For Members And Guests Near The Lake
Tucked inside the Hide-A-Way Hills community, The Lodge turns out surprisingly good pizzas in a cozy, wood-and-stone dining room overlooking the hills.
Access is limited to members and their guests, but if you are staying in the community, the pizza alone makes the Lodge worth planning a night around. Pies are well-topped and nicely browned, with a relaxed, lodge-style atmosphere that encourages one more drink and another slice. It feels more like a getaway restaurant than a typical pizza joint, which fits the setting perfectly.