01
Best overall pick
Park Street Pizza
In The Heart Of Sugarcreek • Farm-To-Table Pizzeria With A Modern Rustic Vibe • Go-To Choice For Quality Ingredients
Thoughtfully sourced toppings, creative combinations, and a lively hometown feel make this the first stop for pizza in Sugarcreek.
Park Street Pizza leans into Amish Country’s farm culture with fresh, locally sourced ingredients and house-made sauces. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to inventive seasonal pies, plus solid wings and salads if not everyone in your group wants pizza. It’s the rare spot that works just as well for a casual date night as it does for a family outing.
02
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza – Baltic
Short Drive South To Baltic • Casual Small-Town Pizza Chain Outpost • Reliable Crowd-Pleaser
Hearty pan pizzas, flexible combo deals, and plenty of topping choices make this a natural fit when you’re feeding a crowd.
This Baltic location of East of Chicago is a familiar name for locals who want dependable, comfort-style pizza without overthinking it. You can build your own pie on pan, thin, or specialty crusts, and the buffet-style options and value deals work well for kids’ teams and family get-togethers. It’s an easy choice when you’re passing through Amish Country and need something everyone will happily eat.
03
Classic takeout favorite
Penso's Pizza – Gnadenhutten
Near Gnadenhutten Town Center • Old-School Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Grab-And-Go Pies
Thin, slightly chewy crust and generous cheese make these nostalgic, no-frills pies ideal for a low-key night in.
Penso’s in Gnadenhutten feels like the kind of small-town pizza shop you grew up with, in the best way. The menu leans classic—think pepperoni, sausage, and deluxe combos—done with a consistent hand and fair prices. Call ahead, swing by to pick up your order, and you’re set for an easy pizza night back at your cabin or hotel.
04
Best for a sit-down meal
Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House
Dennison, East Of Sugarcreek • Family-Style Italian And Pizza Restaurant • Great For Relaxed Dinners
A cozy, slightly old-school dining room and a menu full of pizza and pasta make this a solid choice when you want more than just a quick slice.
Pangrazio’s has the feel of a long-running family spot, with pizza sharing menu space with baked pastas and hearty Italian standards. The crust is on the softer, bready side, ideal if you like a sauce-forward, fork-and-knife slice. It’s the kind of place where you order a large pie for the table, split a bowl of spaghetti, and linger over refills of soda or iced tea.
05
Best for delivery from town
East of Chicago Pizza – Dover
Commercial Strip In Dover • Busy Delivery-Focused Pizza Shop • Good Option For Delivery And Late Evenings
A broad menu, flexible crust options, and fast service make this Dover spot handy when you’d rather have pizza come to you.
The Dover East of Chicago is popular for its thick pan crusts, stuffed cheese breads, and build-your-own pizzas with plenty of toppings. It’s especially useful if you’re staying closer to Dover and New Philadelphia and need a straightforward delivery option after a long day of exploring. Order a couple of specialty pies and some sides, and you can easily feed a mixed group without leaving the couch.