01
Best overall pick
Creno's Pizza
Caldwell • Small-Town Pizzeria With Big Portions • Go-To Hometown Slice
Square-cut pies, chewy crust, and generous toppings make Creno's in Caldwell the closest thing to a hometown pizza institution for Summerfield locals.
Creno's feels like the classic small-town shop where the staff knows regulars by name and the pizza boxes stack up on Friday nights. The crust is sturdy enough to handle heavy toppings, and the pepperoni and deluxe pies are local staples. It is an easy choice when you want a hearty, no-nonsense pizza after a short drive from Summerfield.
02
Best for loaded specialty pies
Guido's Pizza of Cambridge
Downtown Cambridge • Bustling Hometown Pizza Joint • Great For Groups
Guido's serves big, shareable pizzas piled high with toppings in a lively downtown Cambridge setting.
If you are making a day of it in Cambridge, Guido's is the spot to feed a crowd without overthinking it. The menu leans into loaded specialty combinations, from meat-heavy pies to veggie-topped options that still feel indulgent. Expect a busy, family-friendly atmosphere and plenty of leftovers to bring back toward Summerfield.
03
Classic river-town slice
The Original Pizza Place
Marietta Riverfront • Retro Slice Shop • Best Nostalgic Stop
A Marietta mainstay, The Original Pizza Place serves thin, crisp-edged slices that taste like a proper small-city classic.
Set near the riverfront in downtown Marietta, this long-running shop has a bit of old-school charm and a loyal following. The pizza is simple but dialed in: thin, slightly crunchy crust, tangy sauce, and toppings scattered just right rather than overloaded. It is a fun stop if you are pairing a pizza run with a stroll through Marietta’s historic streets.
04
Best for carryout
Plus 1 Pizza
East Cambridge • Counter-Service Pizza Chain • Top Takeout Option
Plus 1 Pizza is a reliable Cambridge carryout choice with customizable pies and quick turnaround.
This regional chain outpost keeps the focus on straightforward, made-to-order pizza that travels well back toward Summerfield. The crust leans classic American, with plenty of room to customize sauces and toppings to suit the group. It is especially handy when you want to swing off the highway, grab a couple of boxes, and be back on the road in minutes.
05
Reliable family standby
Pizza Hut
Caldwell By I-77 • Casual Dine-In Chain • Best For Families
The Caldwell Pizza Hut offers familiar pan pizzas and a relaxed sit-down option close to the interstate.
For many families around Noble County, this is the go-to spot when everyone wants something familiar and easy. The thick pan crust, stuffed crust option, and predictable menu make it simple to please kids and adults alike. Its location near I-77 also makes it a convenient meet-up or pit stop when friends are converging from different small towns around Summerfield.