01
Best overall pick
Dewey's Pizza - Anderson
Anderson Township On Beechmont Avenue • Creative Stone-Baked Pizzeria • Best Sit-Down Choice
A polished local favorite where inventive toppings, crisp crust, and a lively dining room all show up strong.
Dewey’s in Anderson is the place east-siders mention first when you ask about great pizza near Summerside. The menu leans into clever combinations – think pies loaded with goat cheese, roasted garlic, and fresh greens – but you can always build your own. Expect an open-kitchen buzz, friendly servers, and a solid draft list if you want to make a night of it.
02
Best by-the-slice
Ramundo's Pizzeria - Mt. Washington
Mt. Washington, A Quick Hop Down Beechmont • New York–Style Slice Shop • Late-Night Slice Fix
Oversized, floppy New York slices and no-fuss counter service make this a clutch stop on the way home.
Ramundo’s in Mt. Washington feels like the classic neighborhood slice joint every area wishes it had. The crust walks that nice line between foldable and crisp, and the topping choices run from simple pepperoni to heavier combos that still reheat well. It’s ideal when you want something fast and satisfying after a game, concert, or long shift.
03
Classic Cincinnati staple
LaRosa's Pizzeria - Eastgate
Eastgate, Just Off The Mall And I-275 • Classic Cincinnati Family Pizzeria • Best For Families
A go-to for Eastgate families, serving the sweet-sauce Cincinnati style pizza many locals grew up on.
If you’re introducing someone to east-side Cincinnati pizza, LaRosa’s in Eastgate is the easy starting point. The dining room is built for groups, with big booths, kids’ menus, and plenty of shareable appetizers. Order a Buddy-sized pizza or two with your favorite toppings, add a pan of pasta or wings, and you’ve covered just about every taste at the table.
04
Fast and flexible
Rapid Fired Pizza - Eastgate
Eastgate Retail Corridor • Fast-Casual Build-Your-Own Spot • Quick Custom Option
Assembly-line style pies that go from dough to done in minutes, with lots of freedom to experiment.
When everyone wants something a little different, Rapid Fired in Eastgate is hard to beat. You move down the line picking sauces, cheeses, and toppings, then watch your pizza hit the high-heat oven and come out blistered and ready in one pass. It’s especially useful for weeknights when traffic is slow on Ohio Pike but you still need dinner on the table fast.
05
Best for takeout
Donatos Pizza - Cherry Grove
Cherry Grove Along Ohio Pike • Thin-Crust Chain With Edge-To-Edge Toppings • Takeout Crowd-Pleaser
Crisp, square-cut pizzas loaded all the way to the rim make this a reliable pick-up stop on your way through Anderson.
Donatos in Cherry Grove is built around carryout, which suits Summerside residents who want to swing by on the way home. The crust is cracker-thin, the toppings go right to the edge, and the menu covers everything from lean veggie pies to classic pepperoni stacked high. Add a salad or wings and you’ve got an easy, shareable spread without committing to a full sit-down meal.