01
Best overall pick
R' Pizza Place
Downtown Columbiana • Family-Run, Made-From-Scratch Pizzeria • Go-To Spot For Classic Pies
Scratch-made dough, generous toppings, and a friendly Main Street vibe make R' Pizza Place worth the ride from Summitville.
This Columbiana staple leans into a from-scratch approach, with dough, sauce, and toppings that feel more like a hometown kitchen than a chain. The crust lands right between soft and sturdy, so it holds up under plenty of cheese without turning heavy. Grab a couple of large pizzas and a salad, and you’ve got an easy, reliable option for feeding a group after a day out in the country.
02
Old-school favorite
Mary's Pizza
Downtown Lisbon • Old-School Italian-American Pizza Joint • Beloved For Nostalgic Comfort Food
Mary's Pizza in Lisbon is where many locals grew up going for thin, saucy pies and a no-rush sit-down meal.
If you like your pizza with a side of small-town nostalgia, Mary's delivers that classic Ohio pizza-parlor feel. Expect a slightly thinner crust, plenty of cheese, and a sauce that leans sweet in the best old-school way. It’s a comfortable, low-key spot to linger over a couple of pizzas before wandering Lisbon’s historic center.
03
Best for game night
Pizza Joe's
North Columbiana • Regional Chain With Creative Specialty Pies • Reliable Pick For Crowd-Pleasing Delivery
Pizza Joe's is the move when you want easy ordering, plenty of topping combos, and boxes that can feed a whole crew back in Summitville.
This regional favorite is known for its specialty pizzas, from loaded meat options to veggie-forward combinations that still feel indulgent. The crust is a bit thicker and softer, making it ideal for people who like a bready, comfort-food style slice. Call ahead for carryout or delivery to nearby areas, and you’ve got a low-stress option for watching the game or hosting friends at home.
04
Best for crispy crust
Gionino's Pizzeria
East Salem • Carryout-Focused Neighborhood Pizzeria • Top Choice For Crunchy, Cheesy Carryout
Gionino's in Salem is a favorite for its edge-to-edge cheese, crispy crust, and hearty, Ohio-style squares.
Gionino's leans into big flavor, with a crust that bakes up crisp on the bottom and a generous blanket of cheese that goes right to the edge. Their garlic-heavy seasoning and ample toppings make even a basic pepperoni pie feel like a splurge. It’s a great option when you’re already in Salem running errands and want to bring a hot pizza back toward Summitville.
05
Best for loaded toppings
East of Chicago Pizza
Minerva Town Center • Casual Chain Known For Pan And Specialty Pizzas • Ideal For Families And Big Appetites
East of Chicago in Minerva is all about thick, saucy pan pies and build-your-own combinations that can satisfy even the hungriest group.
Here the focus is on substantial, fork-and-knife style slices with plenty of cheese and toppings piled high. The pan crust is soft and airy inside with a crisp edge, making it especially good for heavier combinations like meat lovers or loaded veggie. It’s a smart stop if you’re passing through Minerva and need a one-stop pizza order that will keep a car full of kids or friends happy.