01
Classic small-town institution
Reino's Pizza & Pasta
Downtown Tiffin • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Local Institution
A Tiffin institution serving classic square-cut Ohio pizza, generous toppings, and straightforward, comforting red-sauce pastas.
Reino’s feels like the kind of place grandparents and grandkids can agree on. The crust is slightly chewy with crisp edges, and the sauce leans savory rather than sweet, which keeps the square-cut slices easy to put away. Go for a deluxe or pepperoni pizza and add a shareable pasta or salad if you’re making the drive from Sycamore with a group.
02
Best for families and parties
Fort Ball Pizza Palace
West Tiffin • Retro Family Pizza Parlor • Best For Families And Groups
Retro pizza parlor with big pies, pitchers of soda, and a fun, arcade-leaning vibe that’s ideal for families.
Fort Ball leans into the classic pizza-palace feel: roomy booths, plenty of cheese, and a menu built for sharing. The pizzas come in big, crowd-friendly sizes with a pillowy crust and edge-to-edge toppings. It’s a natural choice when you want to keep kids happy after an afternoon in Tiffin or need an easy spot for a birthday gathering.
03
Weeknight takeout hero
Napoli Pizza
South Tiffin • Carryout-Focused Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Takeout Night
Neighborhood favorite for straightforward, well-priced pies that travel well on the drive back to Sycamore.
Napoli keeps things simple—in a good way—with a tight menu focused on pizza, subs, and wings. The crust is thinner and crisper than many nearby spots, which makes it ideal for carryout or delivery-style nights. Call ahead, grab a large pepperoni or a loaded meat pizza, and you’ve got an easy weeknight dinner sorted.
04
Closest classic to Sycamore
Don Tomasso's Pizza
Downtown Upper Sandusky • Casual Small-Town Pizzeria • Go-To Wyandot County Staple
Small-town staple in Upper Sandusky known for its hearty, cheese-forward pizzas and friendly service.
Don Tomasso’s has the kind of welcoming, everyone-knows-everyone atmosphere you expect in Wyandot County. Pizzas lean indulgent, with plenty of cheese, a softer crust, and familiar toppings that please a crowd. It’s a smart option if you’re already in Upper Sandusky for errands and want to bring a hot pizza home instead of cooking.
05
Best game-day destination
Baker's Pizza Sports Shack
Downtown Bucyrus • Lively Sports Bar And Pizza Joint • Best Game-Day Pick
Bustling sports bar that pairs well-built pizzas with wings, cold drinks, and plenty of TVs for game days.
Baker’s draws Bucyrus locals for big games and big pizzas, and it’s worth the slightly longer drive from Sycamore when you want an evening out. The dough has more chew and structure than a typical bar pie, and toppings range from classic pepperoni to heavier specialty combinations. Grab a table with a view of the screens, split a large specialty pizza, and settle in for the night.