01
Best overall pick
Taglio
Montgomery Road Near Kenwood • Modern Slice Shop And Bar • Creative Pies And Craft Drinks
Crisp, Roman-style squares with inventive toppings make Taglio a destination pie for Indian Hill locals.[3]
Taglio’s Montgomery Road location pairs caramelized, crunchy-edged square pies with toppings that go well beyond the usual pepperoni.[3] Cincinnati Magazine has highlighted Taglio among the region’s standout pizza parlors, and its mix of clever pies, salads, and a good drink list makes it an easy choice when you’re meeting friends from around Indian Hill.[3]
02
Classic New York–style
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta
Montgomery • New York–Style Pizzeria And Pasta Joint • Great For Families
Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta delivers generous New York–style slices and red-sauce comfort in a relaxed suburban setting.[3]
Just up Montgomery Road from Indian Hill, Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta leans into big, foldable slices, garlic knots, and hearty pasta dishes that satisfy a crowd.[3] It is the kind of place where kids can split a pie while adults linger over a carafe of wine, making it a reliable family-night option before or after activities in the Montgomery and Kenwood area.[3]
03
Late-night slice
Ramundo's Pizzeria
Mt. Lookout Square • Counter-Service Neighborhood Slice Shop • Best For Night Owls
Ramundo’s is a beloved Mt. Lookout staple known for oversized slices, plenty of cheese, and hours that run later than most.[3]
If you find yourself on the eastern side of town after a game or a night out, Ramundo’s in Mt. Lookout is the classic grab-a-slice stop.[3] Locals swear by the jumbo slices and straightforward toppings, and its casual, walk-up vibe makes it easy to swing by from Indian Hill without committing to a full sit-down meal.[3]
04
Wood-fired gem
Joe's Pizza Napoli
Milford • Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria • Destination For Pizza Purists
Joe’s Pizza Napoli fires blistered, Neapolitan-style pies that draw serious pizza fans to Milford.[3]
For those willing to make a short drive east, Joe’s Pizza Napoli in Milford rewards with a proper Neapolitan crust: airy, lightly charred, and built to showcase simple, high-quality toppings.[3] Frequently cited among the area’s top pizzerias, it feels more like a small Italian trattoria than a suburban shop, and it is a popular choice for date nights or lingering dinners over a bottle of wine.[3]
05
Suburban standout
Mad Monks Pizza
Mason • Craft Pizza Taproom • Best For Beer And Pizza
Mad Monks Pizza in Mason riffs on classic pies with bold flavor combos and a strong craft beer lineup.[3]
North of Indian Hill, Mad Monks Pizza gives Mason a fun, slightly offbeat pizza-and-beer hangout with plenty of character.[3] Known for creative topping combinations and a rotating tap list, it is a smart choice when a group wants something livelier than a standard chain but still easygoing enough for a relaxed evening out.[3]