01
Best overall pick
Champs Pizza and Pub
Thornville Village • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Local Favorite For All-Around Pizza Night
Big-portion pizzas, plenty of taps, and a friendly crowd make Champs the go-to slice in the Thornport–Thornville area.
Champs leans into classic, generously topped pies with a crust that hits the sweet spot between chewy and crisp. It’s the kind of place where locals settle in for a game, share a couple of specialty pizzas, and work through a basket of wings. If you’re unsure what to order, start with a loaded works pizza and add an extra side of their house-made ranch for dipping.
02
Best lakeside vibe
Beach House Pub
Buckeye Lake Shoreline • Casual Lakeside Bar With Pizza • Best For Sunset Slices And Drinks
A relaxed spot right by the water where the pizza is as much a draw as the Buckeye Lake views.
Beach House Pub feels like a true lake hangout, with cozy bar seating inside and a laid-back crowd drifting in from the docks. The pizza comes hot with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of cheese, ideal alongside a cold drink after a day on the water. Go for a simple pepperoni or a veggie-heavy combo so you can linger over a few slices without feeling weighed down.
03
Old-school local joint
Little Pizza House
South Of Thornville • No-Frills Carryout Pizzeria • Best For Classic, Straightforward Pies
A modest, old-school spot turning out straightforward pies that locals have been grabbing on their way home for years.
Little Pizza House is the definition of a low-key, pickup-and-go pizza shop, with most of the action centered on call-in orders and quick counter service. The menu sticks to the basics—think pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese—which is exactly the appeal. It’s a solid choice when you want a familiar, budget-friendly pizza night without any fuss.
04
Best for groups
Pizza Cottage
Buckeye Lake Strip • Family-Friendly Regional Pizza Spot • Great For Families And Big Tables
A busy Buckeye Lake staple with hearty pizzas, pastas, and enough seating to handle big family gatherings.
Pizza Cottage is a longtime favorite around the lake, known for its slightly sweet sauce, edge-to-edge toppings, and a crust sturdy enough to hold it all. The dining room is casual and kid-friendly, making it ideal for post-boat dinners or team outings. Try one of their specialty pies loaded with toppings, and pair it with a shared salad or garlic bread to round out the table.
05
Worth-the-drive carryout
Crossroads Pizza & Subs
Near I-70 In Hebron • Casual Small-Town Pizza And Sub Shop • Best For Game-Day Takeout
A short drive from Thornport, Crossroads turns out generously topped pizzas and subs that travel well back to the lake.
Crossroads Pizza & Subs is the kind of roadside shop locals detour to on their way back from errands or before a big game. The pizzas lean hearty, with plenty of cheese and crowd-pleasing topping combinations, and the subs are a strong backup option for non-pizza eaters. Call ahead for a large specialty pie and a couple of subs, then head back to Thornport or the lake with an easy, shareable spread.