01
Best overall pick
Champs Pizza and Pub
Buckeye Lake Waterfront • Lively Pizza Pub And Sports Bar • Best Overall Pick
A go-to Buckeye Lake hangout pairing well-made pizzas with a relaxed, game-day-ready pub atmosphere.
Champs is the place locals suggest first when someone asks where to get pizza near Thornville. The crust is sturdy without being heavy, toppings are generous, and there is usually a good mix of classic and specialty pies on tables. TVs, a friendly bar, and an easygoing crowd make it just as suitable for families early in the evening as for friends lingering over a late slice.
02
Best quick takeout
Little Pizza House
Village Of Thornville • Tiny Takeout-Focused Pizzeria • Best Quick Takeout
Unpretentious Thornville standby turning out straightforward, satisfying pies that are ideal for carryout.
Little Pizza House is the classic small-town pizza joint: modest on the outside, but steady with the orders from people who have been going there for years. The menu leans toward familiar toppings and simple combinations, with a slightly thicker, chewy crust that travels well. It is the spot to know when you want to call in a pie and be back home with dinner in under half an hour.
03
Best for groups and families
Pizza Cottage
North Shore Of Buckeye Lake • Family-Friendly Lakeside Restaurant • Best For Groups And Families
Bustling lakeside outpost of a local mini-chain known for big specialty pies, shareable appetizers, and kid-friendly vibes.
Pizza Cottage at Buckeye Lake is built for gatherings, with roomy seating, plenty of big tables, and a menu that stretches well beyond pizza. The pies lean cheesy with lots of toppings, and the specialty combinations are popular with mixed groups who want something more than just pepperoni. Add in salads, subs, and a lake-adjacent setting, and it is an easy choice for families or boat crews coming off the water.
04
Best value slice
Firehouse Pizza
Along Ohio State Route 13 • Old-School Small-Town Pizza Shop • Best Value Slice
No-frills spot where you can grab a hearty, budget-friendly pizza before or after time at the lake.
Firehouse Pizza leans into the classic, slightly nostalgic style of Ohio tavern pizza: a thinner crust, lots of cheese, and toppings spread edge to edge. Portions are generous for the price, making it a smart option when you are feeding a crowd on a budget. It is the kind of place where regulars know the staff by name and call in their usual order without even looking at a menu.
05
Best late-night option
Beach House Pub
Near Buckeye Lake State Park • Casual Bar-And-Grill With Pizza • Best Late-Night Option
Relaxed lakeside pub where a crisp, cheesy pizza goes hand in hand with cold drinks and live music nights.
Beach House Pub is more bar than pizzeria, but the pizza is a pleasant surprise—crust with a good bite, plenty of cheese, and toppings that hold up well alongside a pitcher. It is a natural stop after an evening on the water or a day at the state park, especially when there is music or a game on. Expect a laid-back crowd, lake views, and a menu that makes it easy to settle in for another round and another slice.